Opinion
Join The Times' book club. This month's selection: "Cadillac Desert"
Opinion Editorial

Dysfunction at L.A.'s jails

It's no secret that the Los Angeles County jails are a mess. The FBI is looking into excessive use of force by sheriff's deputies. Internal affairs is investigating allegations that deputies formed a gang-like clique whose members wore skeleton tattoos. Testimony before the county's new jails commission has painted a picture of a dysfunctional department and a seemingly out of touch Sheriff Lee Baca.

Now it is becoming increasingly clear that this isn't just a story of sporadic cruelty and violence but of a department that is institutionally unable — or worse, unwilling — to track and discipline those who engage in such misconduct.

Last week, Capt. Michael Bornman testified that shortly after he was assigned to the jails in 2009, he discovered stacks of incomplete use-of-force reports along with a huge backlog of administrative investigations into deputy misconduct. In some cases, those reports had languished for at least three years, often incomplete or missing key pages, making it nearly impossible to discipline deputies. Information that is supposed to be used to identify and track problem deputies was either never entered into the Personnel Performance Index or only incomplete records were logged.

SERIES: Times investigation into L.A. County jails

It's not clear why the records went missing. But Bornman and another high-ranking official testified that supervisors in the jails were encouraged not to take allegations of misconduct too seriously. In one instance, the captain in charge of Men's Central Jail joked with deputies about hitting inmates but avoiding their faces, according to Bornman. In another case, the department's second in command, Paul Tanaka, allegedly encouraged supervisors to allow deputies to work "in the gray area," according to Capt. Patrick Maxwell. It's not completely clear what that means, but it seems to suggest that they might be permitted to break the law or the rules while doing their jobs.

On Tuesday, the American Civil Liberties Union sued the department, alleging that it routinely fails to provide information on deputy misconduct and prior uses of force to inmates who request it. Such information can be vital to inmates challenging the credibility of a deputy.Baca says these are old problems and that they have been corrected. But there are lots of indications that even after 2009, the use of force continued, just business as usual. We'd like to see some evidence that Tanaka and the supervisors are cracking down on those deputies who fail to play by the rules.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Men's Central Jail

    Men's Central Jail

    Volatile mix at men's lockup leads to high use-of-force incidents. Full coverage

  • L.A., a minimum wage island

    L.A., a minimum wage island

    The City Council is on the verge of finalizing Los Angeles' plan to raise the minimum wage to $15 by 2020, but another last-minute wrinkle demonstrates the difficulty of setting minimum wages city by city. The sooner the rest of Los Angeles County adopts a regionwide wage, the better it will be...

  • 'Housing first': What L.A. can learn from Utah on homelessness

    'Housing first': What L.A. can learn from Utah on homelessness

    Sam has been living in an encampment under the 101 Freeway for the last six years. He is 63, has a bad heart and drinks a lot. He came to Los Angeles from Utah, where he became homeless at age 50 after losing his job. If he'd chosen to stay put, he'd probably be better off.

  • First they came for the pornographers ...

    First they came for the pornographers ...

    In California, road crews wear safety vests, window washers clip into harnesses and pizza delivery boys must buckle up. Should adult film actors also be forced to use protective gear?

  • Can Lifeline close the digital divide?

    Can Lifeline close the digital divide?

    The federal government has been offering subsidies to help the poor afford phone service since the court-ordered breakup of the Ma Bell system in the mid-1980s. Now the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission wants to give low-income Americans a new option by letting them use the Lifeline...

  • The high court and the hijab

    The high court and the hijab

    The Supreme Court this week strengthened an important civil rights statute when it ruled in favor of a Muslim teenager who was rejected for a job because she wore a head scarf. But beyond its practical effect, the 8-1 decision offers a resounding reminder that generous accommodation of religious...

  • Can Bruce Bartlett save the GOP by bursting its 'bubble'?

    Can Bruce Bartlett save the GOP by bursting its 'bubble'?

    Bruce Bartlett has 24-karat conservative credentials. He worked in the Reagan White House, the George H.W. Bush Treasury Department, for former Texas Rep. Ron Paul and the Heritage Foundation. So when he saw Republicans doing things he believed damaged the brand, he said so, and was surprised to...

  • Inglewood tries to silence a critic with a copyright lawsuit

    Inglewood tries to silence a critic with a copyright lawsuit

    You might think that a recording of a city council meeting would be a public record owned by, you know, the public.

Comments
Loading