Grading City Hall: How is L.A.'s city controller doing so far?

Opinion L.A.

Opinion Opinion L.A.

Honking garbage trucks in L.A.: That's no way to deal with Wall Street

What's with the honking trash trucks downtown? City workers try to send a message to Wall Street

A coalition of city labor unions and community activists say big banks preyed on Los Angeles and other municipalities, locking them into interest rate swap deals that ended up costing taxpayers millions of dollars after the economic crash.

So, how do they show their anger at Wall Street? By driving city garbage trucks and other heavy equipment around downtown, honking their horns. That’ll show those heartless bankers!

Really, the protest is aimed at pressuring the City Council to take a hard line with the banks: Bank of New York Mellon and Dexia, a Franco-Belgian institution. Councilman Paul Koretz introduced a motion several months ago calling on the two banks to renegotiate credit default swaps contracts with the city at no cost. If the banks refused, he wanted the City Council to terminate business with the banks. On Monday, the council’s Budget and Finance Committee considered his proposal.

Reporter Soumya Karlamangla, who covered the meeting, explained that the city made interest rate swap deals with those two banks in 2006. The deals seemed advantageous because they locked in what was then a historically low interest rate for city bonds. Then the financial crisis hit and interest rates became even lower, but the city’s contracts locked in the higher rates. There’s no allegation that Bank of New York Mellon or Dexia misled the city or acted improperly. This is simply a case of changing market conditions.

The Fix L.A. Coalition has said these deals are costing Los Angeles money that could pay for city services. It wants L.A. to take a harder line with big banks.

The problem, said Natalie Brill, the city's chief of debt management, is that it may cost the city more money to send a message to big banks than to just stick with the current contracts. A report from her office suggested the deals will save money by the time they expire in 2028 — and more important, it would cost the city $25 million in termination fees to break the contracts.

It’s fair for the Fix L.A. Coalition and City Council members to ask whether the city should try to renegotiate those contracts. A customer can always ask for a better deal. And it’s fair to question whether the city is getting the best rates from its banks.

But the reality is that there is no value to taxpayers in punishing the big banks just for the sake of sending a message. L.A. leaders have confronted this issue before. Several years ago, at the height of the recession that was triggered in part by toxic mortgage schemes created by big Wall Street banks, City Council members proposed removing city deposits and pension fund investments from banks that weren’t making enough loan modifications or other fixes to prevent foreclosures. But the city’s own financial advisors warned that severing ties with the big banks would cost tens of millions of dollars in termination fees and higher interest rates. Instead, the city passed rules requiring greater disclosure on local loans and foreclosure rates by banks that do business with L.A.

In the end, the council’s Budget and Finance Committee made the right call. The city should try to renegotiate with the banks. If the banks refuse to negotiate or terminate the deal at no cost, the city will have the city’s financial advisor analyze the risks and benefits of terminating the contracts.

It’s crucial that City Council members understand the ramifications of canceling banking deals. The sounds of honking garbage trucks outside City Hall shouldn’t drown out discussion of the potential costs to taxpayers of sending a message to Wall Street.

For more opinions, follow me @kerrycavan

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Dozens of protesting trash haulers make noise around City Hall

    Dozens of protesting trash haulers make noise around City Hall

    Dozens of trash haulers and other vehicles encircled Los Angeles City Hall on Tuesday, blowing their horns and clogging downtown traffic as they protested what city labor groups claim are millions of dollars' worth of "predatory fees" L.A. has paid to Wall Street banks.

  • California is falling apart; here's why

    California is falling apart; here's why

    On July 19 the collapse of a "functionally obsolete" bridge shut down nearly 50 miles of Interstate 10. What was the problem? Too much rain, too little infrastructure. Infrastructure? Don't stop reading: Your life, literally, depends on infrastructure. Steven P. Erie, a political science professor...

  • A study of California prosecutors finds a lack of diversity

    A study of California prosecutors finds a lack of diversity

    In one police killing after another over the last year, as the nation has waited to find out if charges would be filed against officers, we've been reminded that prosecutors are in many ways the most powerful officials in the American criminal justice system.

  • Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Given all the other critical things people are saying about Donald Trump, you might think he would (as it were) brush off the jokes about his hair.

  • Covered California's good news on premium hikes comes with trade-offs

    Covered California's good news on premium hikes comes with trade-offs

    The 2010 federal healthcare reform law made it easier for millions of Americans to obtain insurance coverage, but it didn't stop the cost of that coverage from rising considerably faster than inflation. So it was a welcome surprise Monday when officials at Covered California, the state's health...

  • Watts riots, 50 years later: What has L.A. learned, and done?

    Watts riots, 50 years later: What has L.A. learned, and done?

    We look to anniversaries of momentous events — the beginning of World War I (100 years, last July), the end of the Civil War (150 years, in April), the voting rights march from Selma to Montgomery, Ala., (50 years, in March) — to note the passage of time, to measure the progress of the generations,...

  • A note to readers

    In a May 11 post on The Times' OpinionLA blog, Ted Rall — a freelance cartoonist whose work appears regularly in The Times — described an incident in which he was stopped for jaywalking on Melrose Avenue in 2001. Rall said he was thrown up against a wall, handcuffed and roughed up by an LAPD motorcycle...

  • How to kill the summer job

    How to kill the summer job

    I had a lot of summer jobs. I was a foot messenger in New York for a couple of summers. I worked as a receptionist and mail room flunky. Before my junior year of high school, I briefly sold ice cream snacks — sort of yuppie bonbons — on the street for a company called Love Bites. The uniform was...