Opinion
Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion L.A.
Opinion Opinion L.A.
Opinion

Support a secure border, but don't pick on undocumented immigrants trying to survive

It's nonsense to complain that sealing the Mexico-U.S. frontier isn't feasible
Undocumented immigrants need our help

Hands down, the most-asked question asked of political cartoonists is: Where do you get your ideas?

To which my first reply is usually some variant of "If you have trouble coming up with complaints about politicians or politics, this probably isn't the right job for you." Coming up with ideas, or at least topics, has never been a problem for me or any professional cartoonist I know.

Like other artists, editorial cartoonists use their outlet to work out their issues in public.  Many people get annoyed at the president and other political types. The difference between other people and us cartoonists is that, rather than random grousing over beers, we labor under the illusion that we can actually change things (yes, by drawing funny pictures…so we're delusional. Whatever).

Sometimes our cartoons reflect our visceral personal reactions to a news story. This week's cartoon is an example.

When I first heard news accounts of people in Murrieta, Calif., gathering to block federal government buses transporting women and children detained for entering the United States illegally from entering the town, I assumed the protesters were advocates for the immigrants.  I thought they were well-meaning liberals protesting the shabby treatment — such as being held for up to two years while awaiting deportation hearings in inhumane conditions and often without adequate legal representation — suffered by people fleeing economic hardship and rampant crime in Central America and elsewhere.

Upon further investigation, however, I learned that the protesters were actually on the opposite side, complaining that the feds weren't aggressive enough in enforcing border controls.

As a leftie, I am unusual. I agree that the border has been left open intentionally, and that it ought to be secured. You can't call yourself a nation-state without controlling who comes and goes.  Also, it's nonsense to complain that sealing the Mexico-U.S. frontier isn't feasible. The former Soviet Union had a southern border many times longer than that to control, both to keep citizens in and to keep insurgents from places like Afghanistan out. The USSR possessed fewer resources than the U.S., yet it managed to keep things under wraps.

I favor a wall, a strong border. But it will never happen. Republicans actually like the border open because their corporate backers like the effect that illegal immigration has upon wages — lowering them; Democrats know that the  children born in the U.S. of today's immigrants here illegally are the Democratic voters of tomorrow. Both parties are in cahoots on this issue.

 In the meantime, I can't view the human traffic across the border, originating in some cases from countries destabilized by U.S. intervention, as anything less than people who need and deserve our help. By all means, complain about the perfidy of a federal government that claims the right to invade sovereign nations on the other side of the world yet pretends not to be able to control who crosses the border from Mexico to California. But please don't pick on the women and children — and the adult men — who are merely doing what comes naturally: trying to survive.

Follow Ted Rall on Twitter @tedrall 

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Back to school, again and again

    Back to school, again and again

    Even in places that remain in touch with the rhythms of agriculture, few seasonal markers prove as heady, reliable and poignant as the reopening of school. Every September the crosswalks ripen with kids in their back-to-school clothes; the long yellow buses harvest our lanes and streets. First...

  • Compulsory kindergarten: Still a bad idea

    Compulsory kindergarten: Still a bad idea

    Kindergarten hasn't been its old self for a long time. After decades of increasing focus on academics, it recently became more standardized as well; the curriculum for California's 5-year-olds is now aligned with the Common Core academic standards. Kindergarten teachers are no longer preoccupied...

  • Return to New Orleans - an open hand, a welcome home

    Return to New Orleans - an open hand, a welcome home

    Like most people with people "at home" in New Orleans, I found myself both here and there in 2005. By late August, I was daily monitoring weather maps two time zones away. I watched how a "tropical system" gathered force, how it garnered enough ferocity to be granted a name. Katrina looked serious,...

  • Making the Gun Free School Zone Act better

    Making the Gun Free School Zone Act better

    For the last 20 years it has been illegal in California to carry a firearm within 1,000 feet of an elementary or secondary school or on the grounds of a college, trade school or university, whether public or private. The Gun Free School Zone Act, which paralleled a similarly named federal measure,...

  • A treasure hunter, an L.A. park and the curse of the severed hand

    A treasure hunter, an L.A. park and the curse of the severed hand

    Recently I took up metal detecting as a hobby. While Los Angeles is, of course, the greatest place to live in the world, our city parks are too new to offer much excitement for "dirt fishers." The East Coast, with its deep-rooted (though not-so-deeply-buried) history, is more fertile.

  • The hip dullness of Canada's politics

    The hip dullness of Canada's politics

    I spent part of August on vacation in Canada, only to find myself on what was once called a busman's holiday: Canadians are in the throes of a national election campaign, just like us. And, just like us, they're grouchy about the state of their democracy.

Comments
Loading
83°