Opinion
Join The Times' book club. This month's selection: "Cadillac Desert"
Opinion Opinion L.A.
Opinion

Think California should be split into 6? Here's where you should live

Split California into six states? The Chinese Communist Party would call his idea 'splittism'
Think California should be split into 6? Here's where you should live

Silicon Valley zillionaires feel entitled. They like to get everything their way. They order off the menu. Steve Jobs, known for parking in handicapped spaces,  was said to have prompted someone to leave a note on his windshield riffing on Apple's famous advertising slogan: "Park different." So it was bound to be just a matter of time — a short time — before they began  playing politics, and doing it in their usual brash, short-sighted way.

Venture capitalist Timothy Draper came by some of his money the old-fashioned way: His father made a bunch of smart investments that paid off. Like most members of the American nobility, being born at mile 25½ in the marathon of life has convinced Draper that he knows best how to cure everything that ails California:

Split the state into six smaller states.

Draper has submitted the first batch of what he says will be 1.3 million signatures to state election officials, which, allowing for disqualified signatures, will probably be enough to meet the 807,615 signatures required to place his voter initiative — the Chinese Communist Party would call his idea "splittism" —  on the ballot in November 2016.

California, Draper says, is too big to not fail. With six smaller states governed from six new capitals, he argues, these state governments will be closer to the people — geographically, anyway.

Personally, I don't see the logic. If geographic proximity led legislatures to take better care of constituents, wouldn't the city governments of state capitals be cleaner, safer and less corrupt than cities and towns farther away from legislators' offices? From Sacramento to Austin to Harrisburg to Albany, however, there is no evidence of that.

Patrick McGreevy writes in The Times:

“A Field Poll in February found that 59% of California voters oppose a breakup of the state, [Steve] Maviglio noted, and the strategist predicted the business community and Democratic and Republican leaders will campaign against it. ‘There is no groundswell of support for this,’  said Maviglio. California, he said,  ‘is going to be a laughing stock on [TV comedy shows, including] Jimmy Fallon and David Letterman because of this idea. For anyone considering investment in our state, this raises a question of uncertainty.’

“Even if voters approve the ballot measure, breaking up California would have to win approval of Congress, which he said is doubtful.  ‘Is Congress going to give California 10 more senators?’  Maviglio asked.”

The Republican Congress? Give Democratic California 10 more senators? Probably not.

So this is a perfect initiative -- except for its dubious constitutionality, political unpopularity and almost certain unfeasibility. Which makes me wonder: Who are the 1.3 million Californians who signed Draper's petitions? Sure, I know that voting to put something on the ballot isn’t the same thing as turning up to vote and then supporting a measure. Still, some ideas are so dumb we shouldn't have to waste our time discussing them in the first place — and this one clearly qualifies.

Which has me thinking: maybe these people need a place all to themselves.

A dumb place.

Twitter: @tedrall

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Is America ready for six Californias?

    Is America ready for six Californias?

    Can America deal with six Californias? If the pipe dream of Menlo Park venture capitalist Timothy Draper becomes a reality, there will be five extra states along the coast between Oregon and the Mexican border and 10 extra senators voting in Washington.

  • Police use of force: More clamor and a new bill seeking public accounting

    Police use of force: More clamor and a new bill seeking public accounting

    The clamor for data on use of force by police is getting louder, and on Tuesday two U.S. senators added their voices. It's a welcome change from less than a year ago when no one seemed particularly bothered that there was no public accounting of how often people were hurt or killed in confrontations...

  • Can Lifeline close the digital divide?

    Can Lifeline close the digital divide?

    The federal government has been offering subsidies to help the poor afford phone service since the court-ordered breakup of the Ma Bell system in the mid-1980s. Now the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission wants to give low-income Americans a new option by letting them use the Lifeline...

  • L.A., a minimum wage island

    L.A., a minimum wage island

    The City Council is on the verge of finalizing Los Angeles' plan to raise the minimum wage to $15 by 2020, but another last-minute wrinkle demonstrates the difficulty of setting minimum wages city by city. The sooner the rest of Los Angeles County adopts a regionwide wage, the better it will be...

  • The high court and the hijab

    The high court and the hijab

    The Supreme Court this week strengthened an important civil rights statute when it ruled in favor of a Muslim teenager who was rejected for a job because she wore a head scarf. But beyond its practical effect, the 8-1 decision offers a resounding reminder that generous accommodation of religious...

  • 'Housing first': What L.A. can learn from Utah on homelessness

    'Housing first': What L.A. can learn from Utah on homelessness

    Sam has been living in an encampment under the 101 Freeway for the last six years. He is 63, has a bad heart and drinks a lot. He came to Los Angeles from Utah, where he became homeless at age 50 after losing his job. If he'd chosen to stay put, he'd probably be better off.

  • Is sex with goggles safer?

    Is sex with goggles safer?

    In California, road crews wear safety vests, window washers clip into harnesses and pizza delivery boys must buckle up. Should adult film actors also be forced to use protective gear?

  • Can Bruce Bartlett save the GOP by bursting its 'bubble'?

    Can Bruce Bartlett save the GOP by bursting its 'bubble'?

    Bruce Bartlett has 24-karat conservative credentials. He worked in the Reagan White House, the George H.W. Bush Treasury Department, for former Texas Rep. Ron Paul and the Heritage Foundation. So when he saw Republicans doing things he believed damaged the brand, he said so, and was surprised to...

Comments
Loading