Check out the new California section
OpinionReaders React
Readers React

Some thoughts on teacher tenure

EducatorsMiddle SchoolsSchoolsEducation

Thank you to Sandy Banks for enumerating some of the possible outcomes of the Los Angeles County Superior Court decision invalidating teacher protection laws in California. ("Judge's ruling on teacher tenure sends a message to unions, reformers," Column, June 13)

Tenure does not prevent a teacher from being harassed by a principal or fired from a school. Having just retired as a consulting teacher for educators who have received unsatisfactory evaluations, I have seen many cases of unfair feedback based on petty payback. I was amazed by how regularly I would walk into a classroom with an effective teacher who had received an unsatisfactory evaluation.

Teachers still need protections and strong unions; without those, the injustices that take place in the classroom will only become more frequent.

Elaine Mirsky

Santa Monica

The Vergara case might not have happened if teachers unions would take an honest look at their membership and help to remove the very small minority of teachers who really shouldn't be in the classroom.

As it is, unions insist on 100% retention of teachers, while there are clearly some (perhaps no more than 2%) who are detrimental to children and who lower morale for other teachers and create a negative climate in schools.

The unions fight for a tiny minority and end up potentially losing on the other 98% of teachers. This makes no sense to me.

Brian Leung


Let's assume that Vergara is rightly decided factually and is legally correct and that all teachers will be adequate or better. That only solves one-third of the problem.

As I tell the parents of my middle school students, there are three major parts to educational success: the teacher, the parents and the students. If any one part is not doing what it needs to do, success is impossible.

The unspoken third rail of the educational system is parent involvement. There is no one reason why students are not successful. In fact, there may be many. But there is an overwhelming correlation between lack of parental involvement and poor student performance.

As a middle school teacher, I see 160 students each day for a total of 265 minutes. Do the math. At most I have a minute or two to spend with each student.

Without parental support, the student fails. And we can't fire poor parents.

Steven L. Rice

Thousand Oaks

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
EducatorsMiddle SchoolsSchoolsEducation
  • Let the market sort out TV winners and losers

    To the editor: HBO and CBS recently announced plans to cut out the cable middleman and sell directly to the public. These deals pit them against traditional cable operators, which have bet big that consumers prefer a larger, "aggregated" bundle of programming and other services....

  • Why can't Metro rail cars be built by a U.S. company?

    To the editor: On the same day The Times reported that Cal State Los Angeles was nearing a deal with its faculty union, Jim Newton wrote about Kinkisharyo International deciding to leave town and build rail cars for the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority elsewhere...

  • How unfair was Whittier's at-large voting system?

    To the editor: The editorial states that until recently, Whittier voters elected at-large City Council members rather than ones representing individual districts, and that this arrangement resulted in the Latino population being underrepresented. ("Whittier's voting system shift is...

  • Malibu more like Calabasas? That would be an improvement.

    To the editor: My wife and I left Malibu for the same big-time negative stated by Rob Reiner. During the summer months we were prisoners in our home, thanks to Pacific Coast Highway traffic. We settled in Calabasas, where we have lived happily for the last 23 years. ("Malibu's royalty...

  • Becoming an American: Why citizenship and not residency?
    Becoming an American: Why citizenship and not residency?

    It isn't enough merely to legalize the millions of undocumented residents in this country, The Times' editorial board wrote in the latest installment of its series examining the meaning of citizenship in the U.S. today. Better, it said, would be to set these people on a pathway to...

  • Deasy's departure is no quick fix for LAUSD
    Deasy's departure is no quick fix for LAUSD

    To the editor: We all need to realize that former L.A. Unified School District Supt. John Deasy's departure alone will not fix our schools. ("Too many maverick moments finally led to Deasy's undoing at LAUSD," Oct. 19)