Opinion Readers React
Readers React

What teachers think of teaching without tenure

To the editor: I have been teaching for 23 years. This is what the Vergara case, which threw out California's teacher protection laws, means to me. ("Poll shows state voters are willing to weaken teacher job protections," June 26)

I will no longer be advocating for your kids. When any administrator comes up with an idea that negatively impacts students, I will no longer be pointing out the shortcomings of these policies. I am not going to risk my job for a society that does not support me.

Don't be surprised when education does not magically improve if this ruling is upheld. You will get rid of ineffective teachers, but you will also have silenced many teachers who want to make their schools better.

Julie Meneghini, Huntington Beach


To the editor: The Vergara case was brought by students who felt that teachers should be fired without due process.

The animosity toward teachers today, which really should be directed at a tiny minority of misfit teachers, demonstrates the ignorance the voting public has about the profession of education. The majority of teachers are highly effective, and if they are not, they usually leave on their own because of the heavy workload, misbehavior by students and harassment from administrators.

Teachers with seniority are usually more effective than novices because of their experience. Would you go to an inexperienced doctor or a more experienced one for your medical issues?

Katherine Tripodes, San Marino

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • In praise of ethnic studies -- and ethics studies

    To the editor: Ethnic studies does not need to be isolated from other teaching. It can be blended into the curriculum as it was in my American literature classes before my retirement in 2002, before the curriculum became test-driven. ("In L.A. schools, the time has come for ethnic studies...

  • FDIC couldn't cover a big bank bailout without taxpayer support

    To the editor: In response to a letter from California Bankers Assn. chief Rodney Brown about my concern with Congress repealing an important financial reform, it should escape no one that the public is still on the hook when the largest banks face their next financial crisis. ("How easing...

  • Psychologist group fails to own up on interrogation

    To the editor: While American Psychological Assn. chief Dr. Nadine J. Kaslow acknowledges her organization's opposition to torture and our profession's horror at such practices, she fails to acknowledge an important earlier decision by the organization. ("CIA pscyhologists don't represent their...

  • Improve parking, but don't target disabled drivers

    To the editor: It's my hope that UCLA urban planning professor Donald Shoup and others discussing new ways to improve parking in Los Angeles with technology are not defining placard abuse as perpetrated by people with disabilities who legitimately spend longer times at meters than those who...

  • Sony pulls 'The Interview': Some sympathy for North Korea
    Sony pulls 'The Interview': Some sympathy for North Korea

    North Korea's despotic regime is arguably the world's most brutal. It enriches dynastic leader Kim Jong Un and his political elite while the people who revere him as a god-king face deadly food shortages, a total lack of freedom and the ever-present threat of dying in one of the country's...

  • Sony hack reveals the ugly side of Hollywood
    Sony hack reveals the ugly side of Hollywood

    To the editor: The purpose of the mysterious cyberattack on Sony Pictures has been obvious from the beginning. It was done mainly to humiliate executives and expose the entertainment business for what it is: an elitist group of egomaniacs. ("Sony calls on media to stop publishing hacked...