BooksJacket Copy

Petraeus resigns over mistress, but shines in 'The Generals'

Armed Forces

David Petraeus, the retired Army general who resigned Friday as head of the Central Intelligence Agency after admitting to an extramarital affair, was one of the few generals praised in a scalding look at Army leadership by military writer Thomas Ricks in his recent book, “The Generals:  American Military Command from World War II to Today,” reviewed here.

Ricks finds most Army generals – including Tommy Franks and Ricardo Sanchez, who commanded troops in Iraq – to be dull, unimaginative careerists, trapped in a narrow mindset that emphasizes battlefield tactics but ignores the wider geopolitical aspects of war.

But Petraeus, according to Ricks, was able to think both tactically and strategically and felt confident enough to allow flexibility for subordinates, and in the process rescued the U.S. mission in Iraq from failure.

Ricks compares Petraeus to Matthew Ridgway, who replaced the blustery egomaniac Douglas MacArthur in Korea after the latter was fired by President Truman.

Like Ridgway, Ricks writes, Petraeus assumed command with a new strategy, “arriving and soberly reassessing the situation and then, through clear thinking and impressive willpower, as well as taking advantage of changes on the ground, putting a new face on it.”

Petraeus improved the acidic relationship between the U.S. military and civilian leadership in Iraq and acted more aggressively on the battlefield, improving morale among the troops despite suffering casualties.

Petraeus was not a favorite of the military establishment. Ricks calls him a “thrice-cursed outlier,” an officer with a doctorate from Princeton, who liked talking to reporters and politicians, and had made many of his peers look bad with his success leading the 101st Airborne Division in Iraq in 2003-04.

After leaving Iraq, Petraeus led a promotion board selecting new generals, looking for officers in his own mold, Ricks writes.

Although it is too early to determine, Ricks hopes that the Petraeus’  model of leadership influences the Army in the future, rather than allowing the leadership to slip back into what he sees as a stodgy, bureaucratic mode in which seniority is all important.

Ricks writes that the Army “should at least consider ways to keep alive the careers of outliers and innovators such as David Petraeus…”

ALSO:

Philip Roth has retired, he said

You've seen the election; soon you'll read the book

Oliver Sacks makes discovery an intimate pursuit in 'Hallucinations'

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Armed Forces
  • Political sex scandals
    Political sex scandals

    Whether it's on account of an accidental tweet, or a jilted lover, political figures through the ages have been hammered for their personal indiscretions. These are just a few of the most recent examples. Read more: Corey Booker's Twitter flirtations revealed

  • David Shields takes over Dazed magazine -- for the day
    David Shields takes over Dazed magazine -- for the day

    Wednesday morning on the website of the British arts and culture magazine Dazed, David Shields curates a group of writings (essays, poems, journal entries) that foreground “the question of how the writer solves being alive.” The contributors are Wayne Koestenbaum, Sarah Manguso, Ander Monson...

Comments
Loading