ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT MOVIES
Review

'Devil's Knot' offers desolate view of West Memphis Three

Reese Witherspoon delivers a haunting performance in 'Devil's Knot'

Twenty years after the gruesome murder of three 8-year-old boys in West Memphis, Ark., the crime remains unsolved. The killings and the ensuing miscarriage of justice against three accused teens have hardly gone unexplored, becoming a cause célèbre and the subject of news reports, books and no less than four documentaries.

Now add to that list "Devil's Knot," the curiously muted narrative feature directed by Atom Egoyan and starring Colin Firth and Reese Witherspoon.

Egoyan, who has never shied away from the lurid aspects of lost innocence, takes a measured approach that successfully avoids sensationalism. But the film's restraint verges on blankness; a mood of desolation builds in this story of the West Memphis Three, but not an involving drama.

A key problem is that screenwriters Paul Harris Boardman and Scott Derrickson, working from a book by journalist Mara Leveritt, place whole passages of exposition in the mouths of characters, especially a team of private investigators headed by Ron Lax (Firth).

The well-to-do Lax is a recessive hero, constitutionally sad, as though oppressed by the weight of injustice. He offers his pro bono services to defense attorneys not because he believes the teens are innocent but because he can't tolerate the idea of a death-penalty case based on such meager evidence — much of it revolving around the accused's interest in the occult.

As Pam Hobbs, mother of one of the victims, Witherspoon is relatively unburdened by stilted dialogue and convincingly portrays a tough, working-class woman facing unfathomable grief. "Devil's Knot" begins with a playful interaction between Pam and her son just before his fateful bike ride. It's the film's most natural exchange, and its most haunting.

"Devil's Knot." No MPAA rating. Running time: 1 hour, 54 minutes. At AMC Burbank 16. Also on VOD.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 'Chapman' is dull and thinly plotted
    'Chapman' is dull and thinly plotted

    There's a fine line between teasing out a mystery and trying audiences' patience, but the crawlingly paced drama "Chapman" is nowhere near that line. Rather, writer-director Justin Owensby's debut poses a dismally dull question and disappoints with his answer.

  • Jon Favreau's 'Chef' has all the ingredients for a hit
    Jon Favreau's 'Chef' has all the ingredients for a hit

    Writer-director-star Jon Favreau cooks up tureens of fun and charm in "Chef," a welcome return to his more intimate, indie film roots ("Swingers," "Made") after helming such mega-budget pictures as "Iron Man," "Iron Man 2" and "Cowboys & Aliens."

  • 'Legends of Oz: Dorothy's Return' lacks brains, heart, nerve
    'Legends of Oz: Dorothy's Return' lacks brains, heart, nerve

    "Legends of Oz: Dorothy's Return" picks up where L. Frank Baum's "The Wonderful Wizard of Oz" (and Victor Fleming's 1939 live-action adaptation "The Wizard of Oz") left off. But the new 3-D animation feels like a formulaic knockoff of the original, replacing most everything whimsical about...

  • 'Mom's Night Out' a one-dimensional bore
    'Mom's Night Out' a one-dimensional bore

    "Moms' Night Out" is a hectic mess that does just the opposite of what it clearly set out to do: It makes motherhood seem like one of the most ill-conceived ideas since New Coke.

  • 'Broken' proves to be a solid crime thriller
    'Broken' proves to be a solid crime thriller

    The largely involving Korean crime thriller "Broken" finds earnest widower and textile factory employee Sang-Hyeon (Jung Jae-Young) in "Death Wish" mode when his daughter, middle school student Su-Jin, turns up brutally raped and murdered. Despite the workmanlike efforts of the local cops,...

  • Galvanizing 'Fed Up' takes a hard look at the food industry
    Galvanizing 'Fed Up' takes a hard look at the food industry

    Moviegoers would be hard-pressed to find a film more laden with corporate logos than "Fed Up" — and that's one of the strengths of this galvanizing documentary: It pulls no punches in its informed outrage against the food industry, zeroing in on the rampant use of sugar and its many...

  • 'Documented' gives first-person account of Dream Act fight
    'Documented' gives first-person account of Dream Act fight

    "Documented," the first-person account by Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Jose Antonio Vargas, trails his impressive campaign for passage of the Dream Act path to citizenship for some of the 11 million immigrants in the United States without legal residency.

  • A 'real' portrait of 'Big Eyes' artist Margaret Keane
    A 'real' portrait of 'Big Eyes' artist Margaret Keane

    Margaret Keane sighs softly and shifts uncomfortably in her seat. She's just been asked to describe what she felt the first time she saw "Big Eyes," the new Tim Burton film about her life and her art — paintings of waifish children with weepy saucer eyes that became ubiquitous in the...

Comments
Loading