Cameron Diaz and Jason Segel's 'Sex Tape' doesn't arouse critics

Cameron Diaz and Jason Segel's 'Sex Tape' has movie critics feeling frigid

As far as titles go, "Sex Tape" is a titillating one. But despite its naughty potential, the new R-rated comedy — starring Jason Segel and Cameron Diaz as a couple whose plan to spice up their marriage goes badly awry — has movie critics feeling frigid.

Reviews are knocking the Jake Kasdan-directed film for its uneven tone and preposterous plot.

The New York Times' A.O. Scott says the movie is "as wholesome as a spoonful of nonfat Greek yogurt." He adds, "The main reason that 'Sex Tape,' while often quite funny, fails to qualify as a comedy is the absence of any real conflict or complication.… The humor has no bite, no friction, none of the transgressive thrill" that Diaz, Kasdan and Segel brought to their previous collaboration, 2011's "Bad Teacher."

Salon's Andrew O'Hehir calls "Sex Tape" an "awkward and distinctly unsexy farcical misfire" that "sometimes resembles an R-rated Apple infomercial," with its iPad-heavy plot. As for the two leads, O'Hehir says, "they're in great shape and seem game for anything; they generate plenty of good cheer but not much sexual chemistry."

Variety's Justin Chang witheringly asks, "Who should be more embarrassed: the husband and wife who accidentally release a homemade porn video in 'Sex Tape,' or the studio that's willfully distributing 'Sex Tape'?" (The latter would be Sony.) He continues, "'Sex Tape' is an unaccountable drag — strained, toothless and far too tame to achieve the sort of outrageous, raunchy-titillating effect it's aiming for. This is, in effect, an R-rated movie with a coy PG-13 sensibility."

Entertainment Weekly's Leah Greenblatt finds "Sex Tape" "clumsy and wacky and intermittently amusing." The problem, she writes, is that Kasdan "doesn't quite seem to know what tone he's going for, and the last half of the movie veers wildly between crude hard-R comedy and warm-hearted teachable moments."

The Hollywood Reporter's Todd McCarthy coins a new word to describe the movie: "sexcruciating." The script by Kate Angelo, Segel and Nicholas Stoller is "thoroughly preposterous and structurally patchy," McCarthy says, and he agrees with Greenblatt that Kasdan "never finds the right tone or, um, rhythm for an intimate encounter you increasingly wish could just be a quickie."

Among the film's sparse bright spots, according to multiple critics, is the inclusion of Rob Lowe as a seemingly conservative family man and CEO with a wild side. Christy Lemire of writes, "The casting of Lowe, who notoriously suffered his own sex-tape scandal in the late 1980s, at first seems like an in-joke that's too easy. But the more his character reveals himself — and a complexity that's sadly lacking in everyone else — the more you realize how cleverly it taps into Lowe's longtime chops as a standout supporting player."

Follow @ogettell for movie news

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Artists and filmmakers make surprising leaps in 2014
    Artists and filmmakers make surprising leaps in 2014

    Exhibiting raw promise is one thing, but to exceed those initial flashes is something really special. Throughout this year, many filmmakers and performers were pressing on in remarkable ways, showing that even artists who have already exhibited notable skill, talent and accomplishment still...

  • Mark Olsen's best indie films of 2014
    Mark Olsen's best indie films of 2014

    Throughout the year people you thought you knew showed they were still full of surprises. In 2014, when some would see cinema as a storytelling mode and cultural force as an endangered species, these are vital signs of life. Here is Mark Olsen's top ten list of independent films:

  • Kenneth Turan's best films of 2014
    Kenneth Turan's best films of 2014

    What's the point of doing a 10 best list if you put only 10 films on it?

  • Daring films lifted the artform in 2014
    Daring films lifted the artform in 2014

    Like voices crying in the wilderness — rising above that vast wasteland of movie mediocrity — came the roar of the auteurs in 2014. A rangy group with varying aesthetics, they've left an indelible imprint on cinema despite the 400 or so of the marginal that clogged our theaters...

  • Everyone loses in a December deluge of films
    Everyone loses in a December deluge of films

    I try not to publicly argue with film legends, even those who are no longer alive. But when Mae West famously said that "too much of a good thing can be wonderful," she clearly was not considering a film critic's lot in December.

  • Goodbyes abound in 'Night at the Museum' as trilogy comes to an end
    Goodbyes abound in 'Night at the Museum' as trilogy comes to an end

    "Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb," otherwise known as "Night at the Museum 3," rates as more determinedly heartfelt than the first and not as witty as the second (and best). Also, no Amy Adams as Amelia Earhart in jodhpurs this time around.