Health & Fitness

Airborne effects unstudied

CATCHY packaging and celebrity endorsements have done much to make Airborne a hot seller among consumers eager to keep colds and flu at bay. The product, famously created by a schoolteacher who was tired of catching germs from her students, racked up more than $100 million in sales in 2006, after just a few years on the market.

Though individual consumers swear by the product and write to the company with testimonials of their satisfaction, hard evidence of the dissolvable tablets' efficacy is nonexistent.

The ability of Airborne's unique combination of 17 herbs, vitamins and minerals to cure or prevent colds or the flu hasn't been independently studied. The company cites the results of a small clinical trial on its website, but the results haven't been published or made publicly available.

The product contains popular remedies, including zinc, vitamin C and echinacea, which are likely of limited use in preventing colds or the flu. It also includes herbs such as lonicera and forsythia, which are far less studied for colds and flu. And three Airborne tablets -- the recommended daily dose -- provide more than the safe daily limit of vitamin A. A one-time overdose of vitamin A can cause headaches and nausea; over time, too much of the vitamin can cause bone weakness and dry, cracked skin.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Other 'immune boosters'
    Other 'immune boosters'

    COUNTLESS immune boosters fly off the shelves year-round, particularly in cold and flu season. But even some of the most popular immune supplements haven't been tested against cold and flu in well-designed clinical trials.

  • Contradictory findings on zinc products
    Contradictory findings on zinc products

    IF cold symptoms alone don't make one's head spin, the sheer number of zinc options on the market -- lozenges, swabs, sprays and tablets containing various salts of the mineral -- surely will.

  • Echinacea helps fight a cold -- if it's the right kind
    Echinacea helps fight a cold -- if it's the right kind

    U.S. consumers have been abandoning echinacea in recent years. Sales of products derived from the herb fell more than 16% in 2006, according to the Nutrition Business Journal. But the science suggests that echinacea -- in the right form -- may be one of the more promising alternative cold...

  • Oscillo may help, but not by much
    Oscillo may help, but not by much

    HOMEOPATHIC remedies, such as oscillococcinum, contain extremely dilute amounts of natural substances that, in large doses, cause the same symptoms in need of a cure. In the case of "oscillo," as this unfortunately named French remedy is sometimes called, the natural substance is anas...

  • Ginseng unproven in U.S.
    Ginseng unproven in U.S.

    LAST year, Health Canada, the Canadian equivalent of the Food and Drug Administration, granted COLD-fX license to make a specific scientific claim -- something the patented American ginseng extract can't do in the U.S. The claim: Two 200-milligram doses of COLD-fX per day "helps reduce the...

  • Walk through MacArthur and Lafayette parks is a stroll through time
    Walk through MacArthur and Lafayette parks is a stroll through time
  • Drinking milk: the pros and cons
    Drinking milk: the pros and cons

    There are a few things we can say for sure about milk: It is a concentrated source of calcium. It also contains protein and other nutrients. And it elicits strong opinions, even among scientists who study it, about how much we need. With recent studies suggesting that milk may be less important...

  • Migraine studies yield fresh approaches to ward off pain
    Migraine studies yield fresh approaches to ward off pain

    If you suffer from migraine headaches, you're not alone. More than 10% of the population is hurting right along with you, including 18% of women. Migraines are most common from the ages of 25 to 55. The good news: New research can help change your approach to managing your migraines. Here are...