Grading City Hall: How is L.A.'s city controller doing so far?


Opinion Editorial

Fecal transplants: A therapy whose time has come

Clostridium difficile is a dangerous infection that, as its name implies, is not always easy to treat successfully with antibiotics. In many cases, the infection is actually triggered by antibiotic use during hospitalization; the medications kill beneficial bacteria that keep C. difficile in check.

Now, some doctors are treating the infection with a procedure called fecal transplant, an unappealing but extremely effective approach that involves transferring filtered stool from a healthy donor to a patient afflicted with the disease, to reintroduce the helpful gut bacteria. One randomized trial comparing fecal transplant with antibiotics was stopped early because the non-drug approach was so effective that it would have been unethical to continue treating the other patients with medication. Subsequent studies have placed the cure rate at about 90%; a doctor from Mayo Clinic in Arizona describes a hospital patient who had been bedridden for weeks with C. difficile being discharged within 24 hours of fecal transplant.

Last year, the FDA, concerned about how swiftly the practice was taking hold without oversight, announced that it considered donor feces an “investigational new drug,” which meant an application would have to be filed every time a doctor wanted to perform the procedure. The intent was to ensure the treatment's safety, but the time and trouble involved would have delayed treatment for very sick patients and might have discouraged some doctors from offering the transplant at all. In addition, the label didn't fit: Drugs are manufactured in factories where every aspect of their production can be standardized so that one pill is exactly like another. Stool is made by the human body and obviously isn't going to be all that standardized. Doctors, medical societies and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention protested, and weeks later, the FDA withdrew from its earlier position.

Since then, though, fecal transplants have been in a regulatory gray area. The procedure is still being performed, but there are no real safety and oversight rules. Yet without agency regulation, how can it become an approved, standard therapy with accepted protocols? In addition, researchers would like to try the therapy as a possible treatment for other ailments such as inflammatory bowel disease, but the path toward experimental approval is unclear.

A group of scientists, writing in the journal Nature, proposed a solution the FDA should seriously consider: Define feces as human tissue, similar to blood or organs donated for transplant. Tissues must be tested to prevent the spread of disease, and careful records must be kept. Fecal transplant shouldn't be stigmatized as a semi-rogue procedure without strict safety rules; at the same time, the rules should be a good fit for this remarkably helpful treatment.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 'Low T' and the peril of medicating grumpy old men

    'Low T' and the peril of medicating grumpy old men

    Treating 'low testosterone' may do more harm than good.

  • Got flu? Keep it to yourself.

    Got flu? Keep it to yourself.

    If you're sick enough to need medicine, do yourself and everyone else a favor: Just stay home.

  • The dirty secrets of antibacterial soap

    The dirty secrets of antibacterial soap

    Antibacterial soap is great stuff — if you’re talking about just plain old regular soap. Because all soap combats bacteria. It doesn’t need germ-killing chemicals added to do that. The difference is that regular soap doesn’t act so much to “kill” bacteria as it binds to it, removing it from our...

  • Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Genetics trumps claim that The Donald's hair is fake

    Given all the other critical things people are saying about Donald Trump, you might think he would (as it were) brush off the jokes about his hair.

  • Baby on board? Go Navy!

    Baby on board? Go Navy!

    Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus announced in May that he was planning to increase paid maternity leave for sailors from six to 12 weeks. It was one of a number of changes designed to make his branch of the armed forces more attractive to women — and to keep them once they signed up.

  • L.A. to offer a new way forward for homeless

    L.A. to offer a new way forward for homeless

    Most homeless people who live on the streets of Los Angeles have at one time or another been cited by police for various "quality of life" violations: public urination, sleeping on a sidewalk, jaywalking or other transgressions. These are relatively minor infractions of the law, but they can have...