Festival of Books
Everything you need to know about the Festival of Books
Opinion Editorial

What the Copenhagen Zoo forgot: Zoos should save, not kill

The killing of a young giraffe at a Danish zoo — after which it was publicly butchered and fed to a lion — breaks what should be the most inviolate if unwritten contract when humans remove wild animals from their natural habitat: to protect and keep healthy those animals and their descendants.

A spokesman for the Copenhagen Zoo said the killing with a bolt gun of the 2-year-old giraffe was done to prevent inbreeding of the zoo's population. The zoo brushed off other options, such as giving the animal to another willing zoo (and there were several) or keeping it in a separate enclosure so that it would not breed. The zoo said it needed that space for more genetically useful animals.

The action, and the explanation, cast a harsh spotlight on the role of zoos, a role that is increasingly being questioned as we learn more about wild animals and their difficulties in captivity. Humans love zoos, and have for thousands of years. They entertain, delight and educate children and adults alike. But in recent years it has become clear that neither entertainment nor even education are enough; humans have weighty responsibilities that go with removing animals from the wild and putting them on display. Killer whales, which in the wild form close family bonds and travel long distances, clearly were not meant for life as captive performers. These days, we can see how inhumane the old elephant enclosures were. We have yet to determine whether the newer style of exhibits — larger, with softer ground and more stimulating activities for the elephants — will do right by them. Animal protection, and the restoration of critically endangered species, have taken a more important role in the mission of zoos.

More than ever, zoos are taking responsibility for the well-being of their animals, which means keeping them alive and healthy as long as possible. That's not what happened here. And what lesson does it teach the public about respecting and admiring wild animals when that education includes the killing and dismemberment of an animal?

Of course, the zoo's lions weren't about to turn into herbivores if they weren't fed giraffe meat; another animal would have died instead. But there is a difference between a zoo's responsibility toward domesticated animals, long raised for meat, and the commitment it should make toward its wild animals. The wilderness is a harsh place too, but at least the giraffe would have had a chance of escaping its predators there, rather than having its arbitrary death chosen for it.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • A plea to hunter Corey Knowlton: Don't shoot endangered black rhino
    A plea to hunter Corey Knowlton: Don't shoot endangered black rhino

    There are so many things wrong about the Dallas Safari Club’s ludicrous auction of a permit to hunt a black rhino in order to raise money for conservation of black rhinos. Let’s just start with the idea that the club has the temerity to call this effort a “fundraiser,” implying some charitable...

  • How to end ivory poaching
    How to end ivory poaching

    As the second-largest market, the U.S. needs a ban and stiff penalties to halt the trade.

  • End the killer whale circus
    End the killer whale circus

    The documentary 'Blackfish' reminds us that it's time to stop imprisoning orcas in marine parks to entertain the public and enrich their corporate keepers.

  • Mountain lion P-22 should have a real name; bring on the suggestions!
    Mountain lion P-22 should have a real name; bring on the suggestions!

    When we wrote an editorial last week suggesting that the mountain lion P-22, who strolled out of his usual Griffith Park habitat and temporarily hunkered down in the crawl space of a nearby Los Feliz house, should be given a proper name, our readers took up the challenge.

  • Data-security bill in House has some holes
    Data-security bill in House has some holes

    "Hackers steal personal information about millions of Americans" has become a distressingly familiar headline in the 21st century, as online thieves have repeatedly siphoned off customer data from retailers, financial services firms and other corporations. Now, a House committee is advancing a...

  • California lawmakers should pass the vaccination bill
    California lawmakers should pass the vaccination bill

    Anti-vaccination parents showed up last week in Sacramento threatening to leave the public schools en masse, and the Senate Education Committee crumbled like a batch of overbaked cookies. Sen. Richard Pan (D-Sacramento), who has written legislation that would mandate vaccines for almost all public...