Opinion Editorial

End the killer whale circus

SeaWorld would no doubt prefer that the public forget about Dawn Brancheau, the trainer who died in an attack by a killer whale at its Orlando theme park more than three years ago. But that's unlikely to happen in the near future — not after the recent release of the documentary "Blackfish," which explores why Tilikum, a whale involved in two previous deaths, attacked Brancheau during a performance. Conclusions are hard to draw, but if nothing else, the public is learning to ask harder questions about whether it is humane or right to keep these intelligent, social marine mammals in aquarium tanks, performing for crowds.

The film, which opened to overwhelmingly positive reviews, traces Tilikum's early life, when he was captured as a juvenile in the wild, his mother shrieking nearby, then kept in a second-rate whale park with a too-small pool and a cruelly undersized tank for securing the whales at night. He was one of three whales involved in the death of a trainer there before being moved to SeaWorld's Florida park. The filmmaker interviews experts and former marine park trainers who have their own interpretations and regrets involving Tilikum in particular and killer whale shows generally. In the end, though, the reasons why Tilikum or any captive killer whale acts as it does are all conjecture, as are the claims by some trainers that they enjoyed a close bond with the whales. Maybe the humans feel the love, but who knows what's going on in the mind of the whale, which might see the whole relationship as simply a front-flip-for-food transaction?

The subtext of the film is more important than whether SeaWorld trainers have enough expertise or whether Tilikum understood that he was killing Brancheau. We know far more about killer whales now than we did when the 1977 horror film "Orca" was released, in which a killer whale terrorizes a fishing village a la "Jaws." Killer whales form close-knit, lifelong family groups, each group distinct in various ways from all others. They travel long distances in a day and are extremely intelligent. There are no known cases of a killer whale killing a human in the wild.

The public's ability to view these creatures in SeaWorld-type attractions has probably contributed to our collective awe and appreciation, but that doesn't make it right. Marine parks are not aquariums that exist to rescue and study animals in humane environments and to educate the public. They are high-profit water circuses, Cirque du Soleils in which the highly trained performers are intelligent ocean predators that have been forced into unnatural lives. Because there are only 45 captive whales worldwide — and new whales are almost never brought in from the wild — inbreeding is a real concern. India recently prohibited keeping dolphins in captivity, performing or not, declaring them by law to be "non-human people." We wouldn't necessarily go that far, but in the case of killer whales — which are actually the largest dolphins — it's time for the circus to end.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Critic's pick: 'Blackfish' makes case for leaving animals in the wild
    Critic's pick: 'Blackfish' makes case for leaving animals in the wild

    There is a kind of denial we cling to when it comes to wild creatures in captivity. As if the smiling, performing orcas of SeaWorld are content to trade freedom for fish and applause. "Blackfish," director Gabriela Cowperthwaite's excellent new documentary, should change that. The film's...

  • Oklahoma was right to seek stay of executions
    Oklahoma was right to seek stay of executions

    A couple of weeks ago the state of Oklahoma executed murderer Charles F. Warner after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a last-minute stay. The request was tied to a pending lawsuit in which Warner and three other death row inmates challenged the constitutionality of the state’s...

  • It's not time for Congress to play 'bad cop' on Iran
    It's not time for Congress to play 'bad cop' on Iran

    Washington has been diverted in recent days by the drama created when House Republicans — without consulting the Obama administration — invited Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to address Congress next month on the subject of Iran's nuclear program. Presumably he will...

  • Greece's revolt against austerity
    Greece's revolt against austerity

    Greek voters collectively shouted “We're mad as hell!” last weekend, sweeping into power a radical left-wing party that campaigned against austerity. The election didn't improve the country's fiscal health; the government is so deep in debt, it could very well default if...

  • In lethal injection case, high court has a chance to take a bold step
    In lethal injection case, high court has a chance to take a bold step

    In the effort to find less gruesome ways to execute condemned prisoners, more than two dozen states — including California — adopted a lethal injection protocol developed by Oklahoma in the late 1970s in which the prisoner is rendered insensate with one injection, then given a...

  • The influence of science and reason on moral progress
    The influence of science and reason on moral progress

    A century and a half ago, an abolitionist preacher named Theodore Parker noticed something striking about the moral universe: “The arc is a long one, my eye reaches but little ways,” he said, but added that “from what I see I am sure it bends towards justice.” Fifty...