Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Editorial

Free California's transit funds

The impasse has cost L.A.'s Metro more than $250 million so far.

The rising cost of public employee pensions represents one of the biggest fiscal challenges for California governments over the long term. The state took an important step to rein in those costs last year when the Legislature adopted a pension reform law pushed by Gov. Jerry Brown. Transit unions complained about the law to U.S. Labor Secretary Thomas E. Perez, however, and he's threatening to withhold billions of dollars in grants for California mass-transit projects in response. Perez is wrong on the issue, and state officials should keep pressing to change his mind.

The secretary's authority over transit grants comes from the 1964 Urban Mass Transportation Act, which sought to preserve collective bargaining rights for transit workers as private bus and train lines were being taken over by public agencies. The law calls on the secretary to withhold grants as needed to assure "the preservation of rights, privileges and benefits (including continuation of pension rights and benefits) under existing collective bargaining agreements or otherwise."

Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transit Authority workers claimed in November that the new state Public Employee Pension Reform Act violated that stricture, and the Labor Department has since refused to release the grants that would otherwise have flowed to California transit agencies. The impasse has cost Metro more than $250 million so far; the agency fears that $3.6 billion in grants could be lost, most slated for the so-called subway to the sea project.

But the state pension law doesn't eliminate current workers' right to bargain over wages, terms of employment or provisions of their existing pensions. It would eliminate some techniques used to artificially inflate pensions, but such practices hardly seem to be the sort of thing Congress was trying to protect in 1964.

The Labor Department seems to object mainly to changes that make pensions less generous for workers hired after the new state law's enactment, such as raising the retirement age and requiring larger pension contributions. That's a specious complaint. Under long-standing state rules, "prospective employees have no vested right to any benefits prior to accepting employment."

By Perez's reading of the law, states could alter the terms of employment for transit workers only at the negotiating table, even for people and positions not yet on the books. That's a warped and shortsighted view, considering the role pension obligations have played in driving cities such as Stockton into bankruptcy. As Brown wrote to the Labor Department in May: "Bargaining rights are a moot point if you do not have a job in which to exercise them." Just as the state has left current workers' pensions to collective bargaining, Perez should respect the state's right to alter the terms of future workers' benefits.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • White-collar workers are turning to labor unions
    White-collar workers are turning to labor unions

    "There is a great deal of unrest among professional workers, who don't have a history of union joining behavior," one expert says. "They represent the frontiers of unionization in America."

  • Carolyn Ramsay for L.A. Council District 4
    Carolyn Ramsay for L.A. Council District 4

    The race to replace longtime City Councilman Tom LaBonge started out promisingly — there were 14 candidates from inside politics and out, some more serious than others, but enough who were smart, enterprising and scrappy. Now, after an appallingly low turnout primary in a district known for its...

  • Should L.A. really manage the Greek Theatre?
    Should L.A. really manage the Greek Theatre?

    The city of Los Angeles, which has enough problems getting the streets paved and the trash picked up, may now be getting into the concert business. Earlier this month, after a nasty, political fight over which of two entertainment giants should be awarded the multimillion-dollar contract to operate...

  • Bill on drug pricing would help state in figuring healthcare costs
    Bill on drug pricing would help state in figuring healthcare costs

    A new crop of specialty drugs holds great promise for treating or even curing some devastating diseases, but their high cost challenges health insurers and taxpayer-funded health programs. In California, Gov. Jerry Brown has asked for $300 million in the coming fiscal year's budget just for specialty...

  • Shorter showers? Nine more ways the state has to change its water ways
    Shorter showers? Nine more ways the state has to change its water ways

    Heading into the fourth summer of drought, water agencies are looking for ways to get Californians to conserve at home. Tear out lawns. Install low-flow toilets. Irrigate with gray water. But what should the whole state be doing? Opinion asked nine water experts what needs to change about how California...

  • Evolving awareness is cause for same-sex-marriage optimism in court
    Evolving awareness is cause for same-sex-marriage optimism in court

    On Tuesday, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in the Ohio case of Obergefell vs. Hodges, as well as three related cases from Kentucky, Michigan and Tennessee. The court is then expected to decide whether the Constitution requires states to grant gay people the same rights in marriage as...