Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Opinion L.A.

U.S. stores say no to genetically engineered salmon. Someone has to.

The nation’s two largest conventional grocery chains, Kroger and Safeway, have announced that they will not sell genetically engineered salmon. They join several other chains, including Target, Whole Foods (of course) and Trader Joe’s. Now let’s hope the holdouts, such as Costco, do the same.

The Food and Drug Administration has not yet decided whether to approve the salmon, with DNA retooled so that the fish grow twice as fast as conventional salmon. But the agency already has decided that the fish are safe to eat and are very unlikely to pose an environmental threat if they’re grown, as planned, in land-locked tanks.

The FDA’s final decision on the fish has been expected for a long time, and there is speculation that the agency has been holding off mainly because it knows that the public is inclined to look suspiciously on the new product.

The fish would be raised in the mountains of Panama nowhere near the ocean, and they would be rendered sterile and all of them female, to avoid mating. However, the pens would be right next to a river, and the technology for producing sterile fish is not perfect -- it would fail in up to 5% of the animals.

Even this shaky picture relies on the salmon-farming operation being run with maximum care at all times, with no sloppiness, no shortcuts taken. That leads to additional questions of how the underfunded FDA is planning to inspect, continuously and scrupulously, to ensure that the fish farm is doing everything as promised?

PHOTOS: Seven foods, genetically engineered

The fear is that the genetically modified salmon could breed with wild salmon and out-compete them for resources. Supporters of the product say that is incredibly unlikely to happen, but the past has taught us -- as with the possibility of earthquakes and tidal waves big enough to compromise the Fukushima nuclear plant -- that nature has ways of throwing surprises at us, especially in an arena as untested as this one.

Another consideration, which the FDA doesn’t talk about, is the opening of a door. This one operation might sound good to the agency (though it sounds like a potential environmental problem to me), but it would be a very small operation. The fish from this one farm would be a blip on the fish-market scene. However, once the U.S. market has been opened to these fish, the business would grow, the proposals would go on and it’s practically a given that not all of the subsequent operations would be carefully designed and run.

Consumer groups have taken matters into their own hands by appealing to food markets not to carry the fish, and they’re obviously having some notable successes.

The other markets should fall in line; they don’t need these salmon in their fish departments in order to succeed, and, in fact, they stand a good chance of turning off consumers who worry about making over the DNA of an animal that, for all the fish farms, is essentially a wild creature.


The truth about the great American science shortfall

Water conservation's other benefit: It's a power saver

About 3.5 hours of homework a day for high schoolers? That's too much.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Seven foods, genetically engineered
    Seven foods, genetically engineered

    Under fire from an opposition campaign heavily financed by Monsanto, Dow Chemical and other big agribusiness names, Proposition 37 has been losing popularity in the polls. The measure would require the labeling of genetically engineered foods. But it also could threaten the livelihood of...

  • Non-GMO Cheerios are just what the customer ordered
    Non-GMO Cheerios are just what the customer ordered

    It’s good news that General Mills has decided not to include genetically engineered ingredients in Cheerios. Not because crops whose DNA has been tinkered with in a laboratory are dangerous to human health. There’s still a dearth of evidence that they are.

  • On eggs, hens and cages, Missouri is wrong and California is right
    On eggs, hens and cages, Missouri is wrong and California is right

    Proposition 2 is not going away, so instead of fighting it, Missouri should focus on building bigger henhouses.

  • FDA must stand firm in the 'natural' food fight
    FDA must stand firm in the 'natural' food fight

    It has been asked to expand the use of 'natural' to include bioengineered foods and ingredients. Why not tell consumers all, and let them vote with their wallets?

  • Stations of the cross on L.A.'s streets
    Stations of the cross on L.A.'s streets

    The Easter story — which will be retold this week from pulpits around the world — also unfolds outside church sanctuaries, in museum galleries and throughout the iconography of western culture. In the Los Angeles barrios that Camilo José Vergara documents, artists named...

  • What exactly is the allure of Islamic State?
    What exactly is the allure of Islamic State?

    “She used to watch ‘Keeping Up With the Kardashians’ and stuff like that, so there was nothing that indicated that she was radicalized in any way — not at home.” So said Sahima Begum in her testimony before the House of Commons Home Affairs Select Committee in...

  • Ted Cruz's ride on the Obamacare train wreck
    Ted Cruz's ride on the Obamacare train wreck

    When Sen. Ted Cruz, the conservative firebrand from Texas, launched his presidential campaign last week at the Rev. Jerry Falwell's Liberty University, he earned grudgingly glowing reviews from otherwise skeptical pundits. The very next day he drove straight into a pothole on his already-narrow...

  • The GOP's budget gimmickry won't fix the deficit
    The GOP's budget gimmickry won't fix the deficit

    With Congress on spring break, many House and Senate Republicans will probably spend the next two weeks back home touting the resolutions they passed to "balance the budget" within 10 years. But the competing resolutions for fiscal 2016 won't do anything of the sort, no matter what lawmakers...