Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion Opinion L.A.

John Oliver skewers payday lenders. Now, what to do about their customers?

John Oliver's take on payday loans hits home. But how many will heed his call to just say no?

HBO's John Oliver turned his humor-laced outrage on payday lenders Sunday, holding them, celebrity pitchman Montel Williams and their legislative allies up for some well-deserved ridicule.

Citing a study that found 75% of payday loans were taken out by people who needed to take out another loan before their first one was repaid, Oliver said, "Basically, payday loans are the Lays potato chips of finance. You can't have just one, and they're terrible for you."

The central dilemma for policymakers, though, is that payday loans are wildly popular in spite of their egregious terms. Executives of payday companies have cited that popularity repeatedly in Sacramento as they've sought to loosen the state's limits on their products. Countered Oliver, "The customer demand for heroin is also overwhelming, and that doesn't mean it's a product you'd necessarily recommend to your friends to get them out of a jam."

The demand for payday loans indicates at least one of two things about the industry's clientele: they're financial naifs, or they can't find any other way to respond to their financial problems. Surveys by the Pew Cheritable Trust in 2012 and 2013 suggest that both things are true. 

"Borrowers perceive the loans to be a reasonable short-term choice but express surprise and frustration at how long it takes to pay them back," Pew reported last year. "Seventy-eight percent of borrowers rely on lenders for accurate information, but the stated price tag for an average $375, two-week loan bears little resemblance to the actual cost of more than $500 over the five months of debt that the average user experiences. Desperation also influences the choice of 37% of borrowers who say they have been in such a difficult financial situation that they would take a payday loan on any terms offered."

And here's a telling pair of statistics from Pew's 2012 survey: 69% of the payday borrowers interviewed said they used the money "to cover a recurring expense, such as utilities, credit card bills, rent or mortgage payments, or food," compared with only 16% that dealt with "an unexpected expense, such as a car repair or emergency medical expense."

It doesn't require Jet Propulsion Laboratory-level math skills to recognize that a short-term loan will be no help if you're income isn't large enough to cover your recurring costs. Similarly, if you're hit with a large and unexpected bill while you're living paycheck to paycheck, getting a loan you have to repay in two weeks isn't going to do you much good.

Pew found that many payday loan borrowers could afford to handle a loan that they paid off over several months, rather than in a single pay period. But that's a bit like saying a bald man would look better with a full head of hair. The payday lending industry exists almost exclusively to serve the people to whom banks don't want to give installment loans. That's true in part because of the borrowers' credit scores, in part because there's so little money to be made on a small-dollar, low-interest loan.

For years, the extremely low interest-rate caps in California's usury laws made loans between $300 (the maximum for payday loans) and $2,500 virtually non-existent. In response, the Legislature established a pilot program that allowed interest rates of up to 36% on sub-$2,500 installment loans from non-bank lenders, beginning in 2011.

One requirement of the program, said Mark Leyes of the California Department of Business Oversight, is that lenders help boost their customers' financial literacy. Doing so should persuade a percentage of the likely customers that they shouldn't be taking out loans of any kind. Similarly, these lenders are expected to determine an applicant's ability to repay the loan before handing over the money, which is something that payday companies don't do.

That's all great in theory. The reality is, the program hasn't taken off like a rocket (nor have similar efforts in other states). Although the first participant, Progresso Financiero, is said to be expanding rapidly, it is one of only four companies to have signed up. By contrast, it's not hard to find four payday-loan storefronts within walking distance of one another in some parts of Los Angeles.

The real test of the program's success will be whether its borrowers default less frequently than they do on payday loans, said Suzanne Martindale at Consumers Union. She added, "It really is too soon to know whether these attempted alternatives to payday loans will be sustainable for business and manageable for consumers."

For his part, Oliver argued that the right approach to payday borrowers is something along the lines of tough love. He cited another Pew survey finding from 2013, that many borrowers "ultimately turn to the same options they could have used instead of payday loans to finally pay off the loans," such as getting bailed out by friends or selling or pawning some possessions. 

He also offered to mount a "counter-campaign" against the ubiquitous payday loan commercials "to remind people to make sure to explore all their better options first." Of course, with comedienne Sarah Silverman serving as his celebrity spokeswoman and outlining those options in graphic detail, Oliver's campaign won't be coming to broadcast TV. But the point is worth making regardless.

Follow Healey's intermittent Twitter feed: @jcahealey

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Payday loans, online style

    Payday loans, online style

    California is moving in the right direction in trying to crack down on unscrupulous Web operators.

  • How Greek was Alexander the Great?

    How Greek was Alexander the Great?

    Alexander the Great was the first global celebrity: a hero, a superman and, so he believed, a god. Not only did he rule most of the known world at the time of his death in 323 BC, he also became a model of paranoid absolutism for all the Caesars and Kaisers and czars to come.

  • Trump is a bad deal for the GOP

    Trump is a bad deal for the GOP

    Poor Donald Trump.

  • Goodbye to Robert E. Lee

    Goodbye to Robert E. Lee

    To some people, even 150 years after the end of the Civil War, Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee remains a symbol of honor, chivalry and courage; his memory conjures the Old South, a lost cause and a more romantic era. That's why his name remains on schools, highways and monuments across the country,...

  • Now it's up to Greece to deliver a better bailout plan

    Now it's up to Greece to deliver a better bailout plan

    Greek voters delivered conflicting messages Sunday to the rest of Europe about the country's debt crisis. With 61% voting against the terms creditors had offered to extend Greece's bailout, Greeks said loudly and clearly that they're tired of the austerity imposed by foreign lenders. But the country's...

  • A setback for due process

    A setback for due process

    Prosecutors are constitutionally bound to share with criminal defendants any evidence that undermines the credibility of their witnesses, including police officers. But if that evidence is locked up in confidential police personnel files — for example, in disciplinary or complaint records — how...

  • Are beautiful, funny women really that hard to find?

    Are beautiful, funny women really that hard to find?

    "In the history of the motion picture business, the number of beautiful, really beautiful women — a Lucille Ball — that are funny, is impossible to find," former Disney CEO Michael Eisner said in a conversation about mindfulness, of all things, with Goldie Hawn at the Aspen Ideas Festival. "The...

  • And now, back to obscurity for the U.S. women's national team

    And now, back to obscurity for the U.S. women's national team

    Why do Americans care so much about the U.S. women's national team in the World Cup when they don't seem to care much at all about the professional soccer teams that feature the very same women?