Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion L.A.
Opinion Opinion L.A.

Is Pope Francis purging conservative cardinals?

Journalists and liberal Roman Catholics are making much — perhaps too much — of Pope Francis’ decision to remove a conservative American cardinal from the congregation that helps choose bishops. The New York Times said that the pope “moved … against” Cardinal Raymond Burke by not reappointing him to the Congregation of Bishops. That makes the decision to (in effect) replace Burke with Cardinal Donald Wuerl of Washington, D.C., sound more punitive than it might be.

It’s true, however, that Burke is the darling of “rad trad” (radical traditionalist) Catholics and a bete noire for liberals. In 2004, Burke made it clear that John F. Kerry, a Catholic who supports abortion rights, wouldn’t be welcome to take Holy Communion in his archdiocese; Wuerl (and Cardinal Roger M. Mahony in Los Angeles) took a more accommodating position on the Communion question. Burke is also known (and in some quarters ridiculed) for his fondness for the Renaissance finery of his office, in contrast to Francis’ preference for drab vestments.

And Burke recently gave an interview in which he seemed to question Francis’ comments about the church speaking too often and too obsessively about social issues. “One gets the impression, or it’s interpreted this way in the media, that [the pope] thinks we’re talking too much about abortion, too much about the integrity of marriage as between one man and one woman,” Burke told EWTN, the conservative Catholic media outlet. “But we can never talk enough about that.”

PHOTOS: Pope Francis' small steps to lift liberals' hearts

So maybe Francis decided to settle a score with Burke and the rad trads who idolize him. Or maybe he just wanted fresh thinking on the Congregation of Bishops. Or maybe he thinks Burke has his hands full as prefect of the Apostolic Signatura, the Vatican’s highest canonical court.

One sign that the pope is taking aim at ultraconservative American prelates could come in February, when he will hold a consistory to appoint new cardinals. Second only to Burke in the rad trad pantheon is Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia, who went to Houston in 2010 to give a speech taking issue with John F. Kennedy’s defense of the separation of church and state. (Chaput said JFK’s speech, widely regarded as an antidote to anti-Catholicism, was “sincere, compelling, articulate — and wrong.”)

Traditionally, the archbishop of Philadelphia is expected to get a cardinal’s hat. A complication for Chaput is that his immediate predecessor, Cardinal Justin Rigali (also purged from the Congregation of Bishops) won’t be 80 and ineligible to vote in a papal election until 2015. Often, archbishops whose predecessors can still vote are denied the red hat — but not always. In 2012, Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York was named a cardinal even though his predecessor, Edward Egan, hadn’t turned 80 yet (though he did soon after).

YEAR IN REVIEW: 10 tips for a better life from The Times' Op-Ed pages in 2013

So if Chaput is passed over for a red hat next year, his supporters can insist that no snub was involved. Liberal Catholics are likely to offer a different spin.


The dirty secrets of antibacterial soap

Kim Jong Un's reign of fear: What's next?

Hard truths about California's water future

Follow Michael McGough on Twitter @MichaelMcGough3

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Pope Francis' small steps to lift liberals' hearts

    Pope Francis' small steps to lift liberals' hearts

    Pope Francis may never ordain a woman, but when change has been a long, long time coming, even small steps (especially if they're taken in plain black shoes) can lift liberal hearts -- not to mention a pope's American popularity. STORY: Pope Francis: Confounding the pundits as an agent of change

  • Why L.A. needs La Virgen

    Why L.A. needs La Virgen

    Her title in English — Our Lady of Guadalupe — is almost superfluous. She is La Virgen, Mary the mother of Jesus. She appears everywhere in the diaspora of Mexicanidad, the “Mexican-ness” that transcends borders and centuries. She waits on stucco walls, above shop counters and at roadside shrines,...

  • 10 ways Pope Francis earned our respect in 2014

    10 ways Pope Francis earned our respect in 2014

    In 2014, Pope Francis continued to exercise a fascination for members of his Catholic flock and for the rest of the world. There was no papal pronouncement in 2014 to match his electric answer last year to a question about gay priests: “Who am I to judge?” But the Jesuit pope from Argentina continued...

  • It's time to end inaccurate criticisms of male circumcision

    It's time to end inaccurate criticisms of male circumcision

    The recent report by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention should quell the unfounded arguments that male circumcision is no better than or different from female circumcision, also known as female genital mutilation. According to the draft guidelines released by the CDC, the benefits...

  • The high court and the hijab

    The high court and the hijab

    The Supreme Court this week strengthened an important civil rights statute when it ruled in favor of a Muslim teenager who was rejected for a job because she wore a head scarf. But beyond its practical effect, the 8-1 decision offers a resounding reminder that generous accommodation of religious...

  • Mike Huckabee's rhetoric of religious victimization

    Mike Huckabee's rhetoric of religious victimization

    Just prior to announcing his candidacy for the Republican presidential nomination, Mike Huckabee addressed the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition in Waukee. “We are criminalizing Christianity in this country,” Huckabee declared. “We cannot stand by silently.” The Southern Baptist minister, former...

  • Conservative Catholics conveniently discover collegiality

    Conservative Catholics conveniently discover collegiality

    One of the major themes of the Second Vatican Council – the 1960s gathering of Catholic bishops better known for its ecumenical outreach – is the notion of “collegiality.”

  • Catholics, Africans, gays and the race card

    Catholics, Africans, gays and the race card

    The Roman Catholic Synod of Bishops that ended over the weekend was a remarkable exercise in transparency, with liberal and conservative prelates openly sparring over whether the church should adopt a more welcoming approach to gays and to Catholics who divorced and remarried.