Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Students and teachers benefit from tenure

To the editor: Ronald Brownstein is correct that the societal problems that perpetuate social inequality go beyond the Vergara "fix" on teacher job protections. Nevertheless, he fails to address important questions about school reform.

Absent the strictures of tenure, for example, will administrators who have made bad staffing decisions hire the best teachers rather than the cheapest and most compliant ones? Does youthful enthusiasm really equate with better teaching outcomes, or is it simply the ageist meme of the moment? Is the agenda of the educational reformer-capitalists truly altruistic?

James Madison wrote, "If men were angels, no government would be necessary." The truth is that educational reformers, administrators and teachers are not angels. Our schools need rules to ensure that innovation, honest dialogue and a fair workplace are protected.

What is good for kids need not be different from what is good for teachers and their families.

Lorraine Gayer, Huntington Beach

The writer is a former history teacher.


To the editor: Brownstein's piece enraged me. I almost stopped at the sixth paragraph.

As a teacher-librarian, I'm interested in the Vergara ruling, so I read all that I can about it, including Brownstein's column. I was fine until he wrote that "better-performing younger teachers were regularly sacrificed to protect less-effective elders."

What are Brownstein's criteria for good performance? Having worked in the field of education as well as the private sector for a number of years, I've discovered that age has little to do with performance.

There are young teachers who are not cut out for the rigors of teaching, while seasoned professionals are still performing at the top of their game. Age is not, and should not, be the deciding factor.

Sheryl Grabow-Weiss, Chatsworth

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Chances are, schools can't fire their way to high-quality education
    Chances are, schools can't fire their way to high-quality education

    If we got rid of all the really awful teachers in the schools, that would be a good thing. But, despite a ruling this week striking down several labor laws protective of teachers, it would be a mistake to believe that this is going to magically raise achievement levels in any appreciable way.

  • A climate-change litmus test for politicians
    A climate-change litmus test for politicians

    To the editor: I am opposed to litmus tests for political candidates, but 20-something John Cubelic's eloquent plea for political leadership in the battle against climate change and global warming is making me rethink my view. ("I'm twentysomething, I vote, and I won't take seriously any...