Grading City Hall: How is L.A.'s city controller doing so far?

Readers React

Opinion Readers React
Readers React

The new LACMA: Does an art museum have to be a work of art?

To the editor: The primary function of a museum is to display art and to serve as a community amenity. It appears that the current primary goal of upgrading the L.A. County Museum of Art is to create a "work of art." This is putting the cart in front of the horse. ("LACMA redesign avoids tar pits, creates challenges," June 24)

In 1959, an architecture professor I had as a freshman told us that first, a building must be functional, and that if it has utility, it will be beautiful. Utility encompasses all the things that society requires in contemporary buildings: sound structural and seismic design; safety for fire and exiting; disabled access; sustainability and minimal environmental impact; serviceability of power, data, lighting, mechanical, elevator and escalator systems; and interface with the street and Metro.

To glom onto any particular architectural design at this point is premature. It would be prudent to provide only preliminary approval with further study and design development before issuing a final go-ahead. It will be costly to develop the design, but at least it will be easier to establish a realistic construction budget for the project.

Personally, I don't understand the significance of the amoeba-like footprint of the new LACMA. On the other hand, I like the idea of bridging Wilshire Boulevard, as it will better define a sense of place. It would be good to see more use of airspace in L.A

Jared Sloan, Silver Lake


To the editor: Every 10 years LACMA has a redesign spasm. What was once Rem Koolhaas' is now Peter Zumthor's mixy-swirly mess, round two.

The Times' worshipful commentary glides over cost, storage and other lurking considerations. How about skinning the exteriors of the current William Pereira structures with an interesting LED pixel grid for $20 million, out the door?

Bottom line: The public swarms LACMA and couldn't care less about the sniffy distaste for the 1965 mid-century originals. Save the county a pile of money, do the L.A. face-lift thing, and in 20 years people will realize they saved another architectural nugget.

Larry Gassan, Los Angeles

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Angels Flight might not survive 'modernization'

    To the editor: This tiny railroad in downtown L.A. ran successfully for around half a century. It's the simplest line imaginable, with no car couplings, no locomotives and simply a cable connecting the two cars, which mostly compensate for each other's weight. ("L.A. business and cultural leaders...

  • The false choice between fixing roads and fixing the climate

    To the editor: George Skelton would like Gov. Jerry Brown to bring his focus down from the “lofty” issue of climate change and get us working to improve our awful roads. But we absolutely must plan for the future even as we maintain our current way of life. ("California can't stop global warming...

  • Call 'undocumented' immigrants what they are: illegal immigrants

    To the editor: On Wednesday, the national news about Jim Steinle's testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee about his daughter's killing in San Francisco by a five-times-deported illegal immigrant felon was below the fold on page 4 of the California section; meanwhile, we endure innumerable...

  • Don't put the freeze on charter schools

    To the editor: As the Los Angeles Unified School District Board of Education takes on the challenge of finding a new superintendent, I hope it solicits input from the wide spectrum of students and families it serves. While I agree with Stanford education historian Diane Ravitch that our next schools'...

  • Vietnam War vets are 'true heroes'

    To the editor: It's not too often that something gets my “goat,” but the callous remarks made in a letter to the editor ending with the statement, “The true war heroes were those who refused to fight in the immoral Vietnam war,” did. The letter was insensitive and misinformed. ("Donald Trump, draft...

  • Children cut adrift by poverty in San Bernardino

    Children cut adrift by poverty in San Bernardino

    To the editor: We read often about the horrors throughout the world, but reporter Joe Mozingo's piece on the horrors faced by so many children from birth focuses on a group of kids closer to home in San Bernardino. ("No room at the inn for innocence," July 22)