Top of the Ticket
Political commentary from David Horsey
OpinionTop of the Ticket

Duck man Phil Robertson's Bible cannot limit American liberty

I confess my intent is to be provocative by dragging Phil Robertson into another cartoon at a moment when the “Duck Dynasty” controversy seems to have simmered down. But, after all, provocation is the whole point of political cartoons and, now that I’ve got everyone’s attention, I want to share some thoughts about cartoons, religion and free speech.

My rumination was inspired by the 339 reader comments that came in reaction to my Dec. 26  “Horsey On Hollywood” cartoon and column. The cartoon depicted two A&E producers pleading with “Duck Dynasty” patriarch Robertson, to apologize for his Bible-inspired comparison of homosexuality to bestiality, murder and other grievous sins. In the cartoon, Robertson responds, “I say you queer-lovin’ God haters are goin’ straight to Hell.”

Some readers blasted me for putting words in Robertson’s mouth that he didn’t say. To that I plead guilty and note that the A&E folks never said what I had them say either. In fact, very rarely do the funny people in my cartoons say things that their real-life counterparts actually said. It’s a cartoon, get it? A spoof, a lampoon, a satire, a joke with a point of view.

Nevertheless, I can understand how someone of a literal mind could be confused. In times past, the exaggerations in cartoons were obvious. These days, reality -- especially in the political realm -- has gotten so downright weird that cartoons can often seem like mere illustrations.

I have little doubt, however, that the view expressed by the cartoon version of Robinson matches the opinion of the real-life redneck millionaire. He has made it quite clear in numerous forums that he believes the Gospel is the gospel truth. In his worldview, anyone who condones the gay lifestyle would be as guilty of sin as is the sinner -- and just as liable to end up in the fires of Hades.

I side with those who say Robertson has an absolute right to express his opinions. None of us, though, can be guaranteed that we will not suffer negative consequences for stating those opinions. (I, for instance, get called a litany of nasty names by those who post comments under my cartoons and columns and I’m not whining.) Robertson, as it turns out, has not really suffered at all for his statements. A&E retracted its impulsive decision to temporarily ban him from the show, and he has become a huge hero to those conservatives who feel they are engaged in an ideological war with the secular world.

However, Robertson is not absolved of responsibility for his words simply because they are based on the teachings of his particular brand of Christianity. Not too long ago in this country, the Bible was used by some people to justify slavery. Those people also had a right to their opinion, but they were still wrong.

Readers on both sides of this debate might take issue with my cartoon today that more or less equates the Bible with Darwin’s “Origin of the Species.” Fundamentalists will insist that the Bible is the word of God while Darwin’s tome is just a book of flawed human theories. Darwin fans will say their man’s book is a work of scientific fact while the Bible is an archaic collection of stories and rules from a superstitious, pre-scientific era.

For my own part, I find truths of different kinds in both books, but those books have no more relevance to the ultimate concern here than “Winnie-the-Pooh.” That concern is the ever-widening scope of freedom in our democratic republic and the only documents that matter, in that regard, are the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution.

Those documents guarantee, among other things, freedom of religion and speech and the press and the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. No matter what any other document says -- including the Bible -- those rights belong to us all; from Louisiana duck hunters to gay married couples in L.A.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 2014 offers little hope for a more productive Congress
    2014 offers little hope for a more productive Congress

    When the calendar flips from an old year to a new one, we have a sense of being given a new start and new possibilities. Of course, the reality is that days and months and years are human constructs that merely mark the progress of the Earth around the sun. The world we live in on Jan. 1 is...

  • U.N. disabilities treaty deserves ratification
    U.N. disabilities treaty deserves ratification

    The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities should not be controversial: It requires equal access for the disabled and bans discrimination against them in all countries that sign on. There is no question that the Senate should ratify it. The only issue is why it...

  • Congress can, and should, sort out the Internet's tax structure
    Congress can, and should, sort out the Internet's tax structure

    At the dawn of the broadband era, Congress recognized that the Internet was becoming so fundamental to communications and the economy that it barred states from taxing the services that enabled people to log on. But some anti-tax groups and online businesses have hijacked the "Don't...

  • Gov. Brown knows better than to let lobbyists pay for his Mexico trip
    Gov. Brown knows better than to let lobbyists pay for his Mexico trip

    Gov. Jerry Brown is on a four-day trip to Mexico City to talk to government officials there about trade and immigration issues. That's a reasonable thing for a California governor to do. Brown is not traveling alone: Nine administration officials and 15 legislators (some using campaign...

  • U.N. Human Rights Council's anti-Israel inquiry
    U.N. Human Rights Council's anti-Israel inquiry

    Last week, the United Nations Human Rights Council adopted a resolution, S-21, creating a "commission of inquiry" to investigate human rights violations in the Gaza war. Nowhere does the resolution mandate that the commission conduct a fair, impartial and balanced investigation....

  • Democrats' impeachment fixation
    Democrats' impeachment fixation

    "Sorry to email you late on a Friday, but I need your urgent support," Nancy Pelosi wrote me.