OpinionTop of the Ticket

Mitt Romney seems trapped in a rich man's illusions

Mitt RomneyElectionsPoliticsSupplemental Nutrition Assistance ProgramRepublican PartyBarack ObamaGeorge W. Bush

It was a clear sign the campaign has gone on too long when I had a dream about Mitt Romney a couple of nights ago. Other than the fact that the Romney summoned from my unconscious was sitting at a breakfast table with me and was willingly answering questions, the dream was pretty realistic. The candidate was dressed in his ubiquitous Brooks Brothers checked shirt and relaxed-fit jeans. He seemed relaxed, too. But when I asked him a softball question about the personal strains of campaigning, he answered with a generic policy statement.

Like I said, it was a pretty realistic dream.

Sometimes I wonder if Romney really thinks about the questions he is asked or the words that come out of his mouth, or if he just plugs in the lines he's been fed. When asked to offer a new, detailed plan for turning the economy around, he rattles off his "five-point plan" that consists of the same conservative bromides about cutting taxes and regulations and unleashing the job creators that we have been hearing at least since George W. Bush mouthed them in the 2000 election. Does he not understand the meaning of the words “new” and "detailed"?

POLITICAL CARTOONS: Horsey's Top of the Ticket

In the midst of the attacks on American diplomats in Cairo and Benghazi, Romney said President Obama was sympathizing with the attackers -- an outrageous statement that was contradicted by Obama's actual tough talk and four years of relentless drone strikes against terrorist targets. Would Romney have said such a thing if he had taken a minute to mull over subjects, verbs and adjectives before he said them out loud?

The same questions come to mind when viewing the surreptitious video of Romney's now-infamous 47% monologue. In a comfy setting, surrounded by his wealthy peers, he maligned nearly half the people in the country because they do not pay income taxes. Romney called them "victims" who want government to supply their every need. Why did he not stop to think that 47% is a lot of people? Is he not savvy enough to know half the American electorate could not be welfare bums?

As soon as the video came to light, critics -- including many conservatives -- pointed out that the 47% is composed mostly of disabled veterans, retired people, the working poor, a few thousand millionaires with good tax lawyers and millions of former members of the middle class who have lost their jobs. Some further noted that the policy that gives them a break from paying taxes was an idea championed by many Republicans, such as President Reagan. Only about 15% of the 47% are underemployed poor families who receive food stamps and other government assistance.

These facts did not seem to faze Romney. He acknowledges that his words were "inelegant," but he and his campaign continue to stand by his premise that there is a vast swath of Americans who are increasingly dependent on government. Indeed, there are more people receiving food stamps and unemployment checks, but that has a great deal to do with the economic calamity Romney's friends on Wall Street brought down on the country in 2008 and is no proof half the people of this country want to become permanent wards of the state.

Such facts do not matter to Romney. He shares the illusion of the rich -- people such as those in the room where he spoke of the 47% -- who find it comforting to believe money is a reward for virtue and those who do not have money are, therefore, lacking in virtue, brains and drive. Helping out those who struggle with financial challenges, therefore, simply rewards sloth and is bad policy -- especially if it means millionaires and billionaires have to pay higher taxes.

Mitt Romney's biggest liability in his run for president has been the public perception that he is an out-of-touch rich guy. The reason that perception has been so hard to overcome is that it is the truth. Mitt’s father and mother -- both wealthy, but liberal, Republicans -- tried to teach their kid the value of personal frugality and empathy for people of modest means. The lesson, apparently, did not stick with their country club brat of a son.

POLITICAL CARTOONS: Horsey's Top of the Ticket

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Mitt RomneyElectionsPoliticsSupplemental Nutrition Assistance ProgramRepublican PartyBarack ObamaGeorge W. Bush
  • Cowboys and millionaires are in Mitt Romney's income-tax-free 47%
    Cowboys and millionaires are in Mitt Romney's income-tax-free 47%

    In the imaginary universe of Mitt Romney, the 47% of Americans who pay no income tax are loafers, shiftless bums and welfare queens who will all vote for President Obama in November. In the real world, that 47% includes the working poor, the newly unemployed, handicapped people, the elderly,...

  • Neither Romney nor Obama can fix the frenzy in the Arab streets
    Neither Romney nor Obama can fix the frenzy in the Arab streets

    Last week, simultaneous with a mob attack on the U.S. Embassy in Cairo and the slaying of an American diplomat in Benghazi, Libya, Mitt Romney tried to lay blame for the incidents on what he said was President Obama's weak foreign policy. He was aiming to hurt Obama, but did himself...

  • Hiking L.A.'s minimum wage is a no-brainer
    Hiking L.A.'s minimum wage is a no-brainer

    Of all major cities in the country, Los Angeles has the highest percentage of population living in poverty. After decades of slow job growth and stagnant wages, 28% of Angelenos — 1 million people — today live below the poverty line. Our city's African American and Latino...

  • The government vs. the Constitution

    The American Civil Liberties Union and other organizations recently filed a lawsuit accusing the federal government of, among other lapses, denying due process to mothers with children detained at the border, including interfering with their efforts to obtain legal advice to guide them in...

  • Has L.A.'s economy come back?
    Has L.A.'s economy come back?

    Among those who know Los Angeles' economy best, there is one point of agreement: The city is slowly recovering from the 2007 collapse. It was seven years ago that a national housing and financial crisis triggered the worst economic downturn of this generation, and it hit L.A. hard....

  • The new battle over Blair Mountain -- with lawyers instead of guns
    The new battle over Blair Mountain -- with lawyers instead of guns

    In late August 1921, long-running tensions between pro-union miners and anti-union West Virginia coal operators erupted into an armed confrontation totaling well over 10,000 men, a mess of bullets and a still-unconfirmed number of dead and wounded during five days of gunfighting at a spot...