Each week the nation’s top “American Idol” pundits will put their reputations on the line and attempt to predict the fate of our contestants. Throughout the semi-finals check back each week (the morning after performance shows) to see who our pundits are predicting will be going home. Who is the king of all Idol watchers? Find out here!
| PANELISTS | IDOLS |
 Kristen McNamara |  Lil Rounds |  Nathaniel Marshall |  Scott MacIntyre |  Taylor Vaifanua |  Von Smith |
| Next » |
| Jeremy Blacklow, Access Hollywood |  | |||||
| Brill Bundy, Zap2It.com | | | ||||
| Andrea Engstrom, Yahoo! | | |||||
| Maria Elena Fernandez, Los Angeles Times | | | ||||
| Shirley Halperin, Billboard | | | ||||
| Joseph Anthony Kapsch, Los Angeles Times, Zap2It.com | | | | |||
| Amir Kenan, Metromix.com | | | ||||
| Shawna Malcom, People | | | ||||
| Brian Mansfield, USA Today | | | ||||
| Martin Miller, Los Angeles Times | | | ||||
| Rick Porter, Zap2It.com | | | ||||
| Richard Rushfield, Los Angeles Times | | | ||||
| Laura Saltman, Access Hollywood | | | | |||
| MJ Santilli, MJ's Blog | | | ||||
| Matt Whitfield, Yahoo! | | |