Books Jacket Copy
Review

In Amy Bloom's 'Lucky Us,' sisters remain plucky in face of tragedy

'Lucky Us' by Amy Bloom keeps the reader at an emotional remove
Amy Bloom's new novel 'Lucky Us' moves from character to character with the elusive texture of a reverie

"There is no such thing as a good writer and a bad liar," Amy Bloom wrote in her 1999 short story "The Story," which remains my favorite of all her work. It's a vivid bit of double vision, Bloom commenting on the process of storytelling even as she engages in it, and it suggests an edge, a brittle humor that I associate with her. In "The Story," Bloom describes a widow, coming to terms with new neighbors she calls the Golddust Twins — until, halfway through, she changes direction, bringing her narrator out from behind the fictive veil.

"I have made the best and happiest ending that I can in this world," the character (who may or may not be a version of Bloom) announces, "made it out of the flax and netting and leftover trim of someone else's life, I know, but made it to keep the innocent safe and the guilty punished, and I have made it as the world should be and not as I have found it."

I kept thinking about "The Story" as I read Bloom's new novel "Lucky Us," looking for its bite. This is one disappointment of the book, which unfolds with a distressing lack of friction, leaving us with little about which to care. The story of half-sisters Eva and Iris, who end up first in Hollywood and then in Brooklyn after having left their ne'er-do-well father in the early days of World War II, "Lucky Us" is an attempt at an American picaresque in the style of, say, John Irving, or Bloom's most recent novel, "Away" (2007), which involved a Russian immigrant who literally walks home from New York.

This is not realism, exactly, but something just a bit more heightened, in which naturalism blurs into fable, and the boundaries between reality and dream fade away. "I don't think the best beginning is loneliness or the memory of a man making you laugh while your sister is kissing his wife in the backyard or the strong feeling that if you do not leap now, unprepared and inept as you are, onto this buckling train, you may be sorry," Eva tells us, "but I don't think it's the worst."

What Eva (and Bloom) is talking about is story, which is all we have to shape experience, to create the world as it should be. It's a point she makes explicit throughout "Lucky Us," which moves from voice to voice, from character to character, with the elusive texture of a reverie.

Eva and Iris are the center of a floating opera of a household, which includes, after a while, their long-lost father, a gay makeup artist from Hollywood, Iris' lesbian lover, and a boy, Danny, who they steal (or liberate) from a Jewish orphanage. Late in the novel, Danny and Eva tell each other where he came from: "Danny was born to his mother and father and brother," the boy begins. "When Danny was very little … his mother died. He was too little to know what happened but Danny had a brother, Bobby, and Bobby said that their mother fell off a roof and their father was so sad and so messed up, he had to take Danny and Bobby to the orphanage, to take care of them."

Bloom is offering a glimpse of story as creation myth. And yet, unlike the narrator of "The Story," who recognizes the need to tell stories as a reaction to the messiness, the treachery, of living, the characters in "Lucky Us" rarely are so self-aware.

It's not that they haven't been transfigured by tragedy; people die, children are abandoned, there is poverty and betrayal and collapse. Still, the forward movement of the novel is so relentlessly cheery, so much about adversity overcome rather than adversity undertaken, that it all begins to feel a little Horatio Alger-esque.

In part, this is a result of Bloom's tone throughout the book, which is oddly flat and on-the-surface; she tells this story as if it is already done. That may be unavoidable, given that it takes place in the 1940s, but there is a distance even in the intimate moments that keeps us at an emotional remove.

"I looked for mothers the way drunks look for bars," Eva reflects, as if to highlight her feeling of abandonment. There is, however, no fallout, no sense of how what she is missing has shaped her, nothing except a kind of native pluckiness, which never seems completely real.

In the end, this is the issue with "Lucky Us": We don't believe it, not enough. "I remember some things at a gallop," Iris writes in a letter, "some moments … bearing down upon me in huge detail, and other things that are no more than small leaves floating on a stream. Memory seems as faulty, as misunderstood and misguided, as every other thought or spasm that passes through us."

That's a beautiful passage, and I'd be remiss if I did not point out that "Lucky Us" is full of such observations, so sharp they pierce the heart. Memory, though — or, in this case, narrative — needs to be framed if it is to resonate. With "Lucky Us," Bloom never quite puts the pieces together. Or perhaps it is more accurate to say that her characters, or their story, or the world they live in, lack "the flax and netting and leftover trim" of life.

david.ulin@latimes.com

Follow me on Twitter @davidulin

Lucky Us
A Novel

Amy Bloom
Random House: 240 pp., $26

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • 'Tigerman' finds Nick Harkaway in retro superhero mode
    'Tigerman' finds Nick Harkaway in retro superhero mode

    Nick Harkaway's fiction grapples with the curious power of genre fiction's cheap, potent end, from the post-apocalyptic kung fu of "The Gone-Away World" to the clockwork bees and London gangsters of "Angelmaker." His third novel, "Tigerman," sets the familiar elements of gaudy old superhero...

  • 'Unruly Places' is a guide to weird, ruined and wonderful spots
    'Unruly Places' is a guide to weird, ruined and wonderful spots

    I've been to only three of the "unruly places" featured in Alastair Bonnett's terrific new book (the City of the Dead in Cairo, the "Time Landscape" in Manhattan, and International Airspace). If that seems a low number, bear in mind that other locations include Pripyat, the town adjacent to...

  • Trying to make sense of the world of ubiquitous surveillance
    Trying to make sense of the world of ubiquitous surveillance

    Airports are exemplars of our surveillance society. Here a raft of digital surveillance, targeting and sorting systems come together. And they start working well before you arrive for check-in, with the U.S. government comparing your name against watch lists as soon as you buy a ticket.

  • India bans 'Fifty Shades of Grey' film, but the book's a hit there
    India bans 'Fifty Shades of Grey' film, but the book's a hit there

    Indian censors have decided the movie "Fifty Shades of Grey" is too sexy to be released there. Don't tell them the book is on their bestseller lists.

  • Dennis Lehane drinks in some sunlight
    Dennis Lehane drinks in some sunlight

    Dennis Lehane is one of Boston's best-known writers. Born and raised in the community of Dorchester (or, as he would pronounce it, "Dorchestah"), he's got a Bostonian no-nonsense, tough-guy edge, and his books, including "Mystic River" and the six-book Kenzie-Gennaro mystery series, are set...

  • Indie spotlight: Pushkin Press
    Indie spotlight: Pushkin Press

    When Wes Anderson's "The Grand Budapest Hotel" won Oscars for its costumes, makeup, score and production design, it swept something else along in its winning tide: Austrian writer Stefan Zweig. The long-deceased author, who wrote in German, penned the personal stories that were the film's...

  • Elizabeth McCracken wins the Story Prize
    Elizabeth McCracken wins the Story Prize

    Elizabeth McCracken is the recipient of the $20,000 Story Prize for her collection “Thunderstruck.” McCracken was awarded the short-fiction prize Wednesday night at a ceremony in New York.

  • Poetry makes a difference in 'Please Excuse This Poem'
    Poetry makes a difference in 'Please Excuse This Poem'

    “Most poets,” Carolyn Forché writes, in the introduction to Brett Fletcher Lauer and Lynn Melnick’s anthology “Please Excuse This Poem: 100 New Poets for the Next Generation” (Viking: 290 pp., $16.99), “begin writing poetry in secret.” It’s...

Comments
Loading