Two men charged with severely beating
Marvin Norwood, 30, and Louie Sanchez, 31, faced charges of mayhem, assault and battery, and inflicting great bodily injury in the beating of Stow, a 44-year-old father of two.
The March 31 attack left Stow, a Northern California paramedic, with serious head trauma and a permanent disability that means he will need care for the rest of his life.
[Updated, 10:05 a.m. PST Feb. 20: Superior Court Judge George G. Lomeli addressed both men at the hearing, calling them the "biggest nightmare" for people who attend public events.
"You not only ruined the life of Mr. Stow, the obvious victim, but his children, his spouse, his family, his friends," Lomeli said. "One day you'll be released ... and Mr. Stow will be forever trapped in the medical condition you caused him. Only because of the love of his family may he be able to manage this."
As Sanchez smiled, looked down and shook his head, the judge went on to call the attack "absolutely brutal, absolutely vicious. In my opinion, cowardice."]
Stow was attacked as he and three other Giants fans, all Bay Area paramedics, walked through the parking lot after the
According to witnesses, Stow said he hoped that two men who had launched a verbal assault would "code,” paramedic slang for having a heart attack, and that one of the men, later identified as Sanchez shoved Stow. The paramedics took off to avoid a confrontation but a few minutes later the two assailants accosted Stow and his friends.
Witnesses said Stow was sucker-punched, falling to the ground and fracturing his skull. Once on the ground, Stow was kicked in the ribs and head, they said.
None of the witnesses could positively identify Sanchez or Norwood as having delivered the punch, and many of those closest to the altercation were unable to pick either defendant out during police lineups.
But ultimately, the words the two men spoke in jail after their arrest in July 2011 -- unaware they were being recorded -- made it hard for them to deny their role in the brutal beating, officials said. Those statements, along with testimony from Dorene Sanchez, Sanchez's sister and Norwood's fiancee, placed them at the scene of the crime.
In a 12-minute recorded conversation, the two expressed amazement at the evidence detectives had amassed against them, with one remarking that police "know everything, bro" and the other saying, "Wow, we're done."
"How much time do you think we are going to get?" Norwood asked.
"A lot," replied Sanchez.
Placed together in a holding cell as they awaited a police lineup, the men immediately began comparing notes about the evidence and discussed what Sanchez's 10-year-old son would say.
"I socked him, jumped him and started beating him," Sanchez said, apologizing to Norwood for getting him involved in the violence.
"That happens, bro," Norwood replied. "I mean, what kind of man would I have been if I hadn't jumped in."
In another recording, Norwood told his mother that he had been arrested for "that Dodger Stadium thing" and admitted he "was involved." In finding there was enough evidence for the two to stand trial last year, a judge noted that Norwood had tried initially to act as a peacemaker when Sanchez taunted and attacked rival fans, but that he had later joined in the violence.
But Dorene Sanchez of Rialto testified at a preliminary hearing in 2012, after being granted immunity, that she never witnessed the beating, although her statements placed the two at the scene.
She said Norwood and her brother had run after the Giants fans and returned shaken and, in Norwood's case, with blood on his hands. Norwood is the father of her 2-year-old child.
Dorene Sanchez was originally booked with the men as an accessory after the fact, for driving them from the ballpark, but she began cooperating with prosecutors, who subsequently opted not to pursue charges against her.
The incident drew national attention and calls for police, city officials and the Dodgers to tighten stadium security and better protect fans.