Opinion
Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion Editorial

Learning from the Kelly Thomas case

The death of homeless, schizophrenic Kelly Thomas after a beating by two Fullerton police officers was shocking. Anyone who has seen the grainy but graphic 33-minute video of the incident must acknowledge that it is hard to square with the jury's conclusion that the two officers were not guilty of second-degree murder, involuntary manslaughter or even of using excessive force.

The verdict is a reminder of how difficult it is to convict police officers in such cases, because the law explicitly allows them to use deadly force to protect themselves, if necessary, in the line of duty. What's more, even the most horrific video tells only part of the story, and the jury, which had the final say, ultimately concluded after watching it and listening to testimony and sifting through evidence that the officers should go free.

But no one should conclude from the acquittal that nothing went wrong that night in Fullerton, or that the high legal bar for convicting police officers means that violence is an acceptable way for police to handle a mentally ill suspect.

Attorneys for Manuel Ramos and Jay Cicinelli said the lawmen were just doing their jobs. "They did what they were trained to do," attorney John Barnett told The Times.

And that's the problem. Responsibility for dealing with the mentally ill often falls to the officers who patrol the streets, and they need better training and support to do so safely. Police routinely confront men and women who are erratic or irrational, and they are forced make split-second decisions on whether these individuals pose a deadly risk. Yet too few officers across the country receive adequate training or clear protocols on how to defuse, rather than escalate, dangerous confrontations with the mentally ill.

Some states offer specialized training, and some agencies have enacted their own protocols. Following a 1999 incident in which a Los Angeles police officer shot and killed a mentally ill woman after she lunged at him with a screwdriver, the LAPD required officers to complete eight hours of training. Plainclothes police and social workers are deployed when an officer encounters someone who may suffer from mental illness.

In Orange County, only a handful of officers were trained to deal with the mentally ill before the Kelly Thomas incident. California needs a broad, statewide revamping of training and standards for such situations, including state legislation to force sluggish police departments to catch up. Those standards should be worked out in cooperation with medical professionals.

The broader problem is the lack of a comprehensive, treatment-based response to mental illness and the default decision to treat the symptoms and side effects — drug abuse, erratic behavior or homelessness — as entry points into the criminal justice system instead of the healthcare system. Until that changes, confrontations between police and the mentally ill will continue. Thomas' death was a terrible mistake. It would be tragedy if the Fullerton Police Department and other agencies did not learn from it.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Two former officers found not guilty in death of Kelly Thomas

    Two former officers found not guilty in death of Kelly Thomas

    Manuel Ramos and Jay Cicinelli are acquitted of murder and manslaughter charges in the 2011 beating death of transient Kelly Thomas.

  • Through fiction, veterans present a clearer truth on U.S. wars

    Through fiction, veterans present a clearer truth on U.S. wars

    Here's a summer reading suggestion you probably didn't see coming: Try some of the excellent recent fiction produced about America's wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, much of it by veterans.

  • Wanted: True oversight of the L.A. County Sheriff's Department

    Wanted: True oversight of the L.A. County Sheriff's Department

    Los Angeles County has a commission created more than a half century ago, that is tasked with monitoring jail conditions and holding government accountable for improper treatment of inmates. As reports circulated in recent years of inmate beatings and abuse at the hands of sheriff's deputies, the...

  • Jailing fewer at the border

    Jailing fewer at the border

    The Department of Homeland Security announced recently that it would release hundreds of mothers and children who are seeking political asylum, so that they can await their hearings in freedom rather than in detention facilities. That was a welcome move, but the government should go further and...

  • Alexander von Humboldt: The man who made nature modern

    Alexander von Humboldt: The man who made nature modern

    His contemporaries considered Alexander von Humboldt the most famous man in the world after Napoleon, and Thomas Jefferson called him “one of the greatest ornaments of the age.” There are more plants, animals, minerals and places named after Humboldt than any other person. In California alone,...

  • What would Jesus say about same-sex marriage?

    What would Jesus say about same-sex marriage?

    Amid all of the overheated rhetoric surrounding the Supreme Court's decision legalizing same-sex marriages across the nation, evangelicals have alternated between defiance and a kind of martyrdom.

Comments
Loading