Monterey Shale finding is a setback and an opportunity for California

Environmental PoliticsEnergy ResourcesPetroleum IndustryU.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Downgrading the riches of the Monterey Shale: jumbled geology, multiple fault lines and thick, sticky oil
Calif. needed the oil bonanza, but there is another way of looking at the downgrading of the Monterey Shale

A new federal report that drastically downgrades the short-term oil potential of the Monterey Shale is the most official word on the subject, but not the first. Two years ago, a Wall Street analyst, in a report titled "The Mystery of the Missing Monterey Shale," outlined possible reasons why the oil-rich California geological formation had been a disappointment in recent years and was unlikely to produce a fracking boom like the one in North Dakota. Jumbled geology, multiple fault lines and thick, sticky oil were among the explanations.

The latest report by the U.S. Energy Information Administration reduces by 96% the 2011 estimate by a government contractor of how much oil can be extracted via existing technology: 600 million barrels instead of 13.7 billion barrels.

The information is probably disappointing to Gov. Jerry Brown and others who believed California was on the verge of creating close to 3 million new jobs and $25 million a year in additional tax revenue through fracking of the Monterey Shale, which runs under much of the Central Valley and sections of the coast, including Los Angeles. But as much as the state needs the bonanza, there is another way of looking at the news: The difficulties in drilling, fracking or otherwise tapping the shale's riches give California an important chance to pause and study the matter.

The Monterey Shale isn't going anywhere; petroleum companies, once they're closer to exhausting the more easily obtained oil in North Dakota's Bakken formation, will almost certainly work to develop the technology that unlocks California's oil deposits. But now there is time to observe the longer-term environmental and economic impacts of fracking.

California officials can analyze what's happening in other states and examine the academic and government studies that will be emerging. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is still working on a comprehensive study that has been in the works since 2011. California would have time to conduct its own studies, especially on how fracking might affect earthquake risk in an area so riddled with faults. Better yet, it would have time to build a more robust portfolio of sustainable energy projects that do not contribute to climate change, and to rethink whether it wants to continue relying on the fossil fuels that are so damaging to the environment.

The state already has begun its studies, and it should not use the latest news as a reason to put off its work. In addition, the Legislature should pass a bill to impose a moratorium on fracking and other well-stimulation activities until those studies are completed. When the petroleum industry has developed more effective technologies for extracting the shale's resources, California will be better prepared because of the delay.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Environmental PoliticsEnergy ResourcesPetroleum IndustryU.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  • 'Fracking' the Monterey Shale -- boon or boondoggle?
    'Fracking' the Monterey Shale -- boon or boondoggle?

    Extracting oil and gas from the California formation could bring the state economic prosperity — or it could be an environmental disaster.

  • America's mass-shootings epidemic
    America's mass-shootings epidemic

    It's not a matter of if, but when and where the next mass shooting will happen: It might take place at another shopping mall, or college campus, or suburban office building, and probably not long from now. Yet, as these disturbing incidents keep appearing in the headlines, various...

  • No winners in this MTA train wreck
    No winners in this MTA train wreck

    It's hard to find winners in the meltdown that occurred last week at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. A Japanese rail car manufacturing company trying to build a plant in Palmdale announced it was tired of fighting a union-supported environmental challenge and instead would...

  • Sharing the roads in L.A.
    Sharing the roads in L.A.

    Motorists unite! An advisory initiative on San Francisco's November ballot urges city leaders to reverse their public transit and bicycle-friendly policies. Because 79% of households in the city have a car, proponents argue, wouldn't it make more sense to dedicate more money to...

  • Why U.S. citizenship matters
    Why U.S. citizenship matters

    To most Americans, it may seem obvious that someone permanently residing in the United States should be able — and should desire — to become a U.S. citizen. Yet in the debate over legalizing some 11 million immigrants living in this country without authorization, many advocates...

  • Will private industry follow Obama's lead on credit-card security?
    Will private industry follow Obama's lead on credit-card security?

    The Obama administration did its part to speed the switch to more secure credit cards Friday when the president signed an executive order requiring government agencies to start switching to the next generation of cards by January. How much effect this move will have on private industry,...