OpinionEditorial

LAPD should name names in officer-involved shootings

Crime, Law and JusticeLaw EnforcementShootingsCrimeLos Angeles Police DepartmentCourts and the JudiciaryChristopher Dorner

The public knows a great deal more now about a Los Angeles Police Department shooting than it did a few weeks ago. We know that officers fired more than 100 shots into and at a truck in Torrance on the morning of Feb. 7, 2013, only to discover that fleeing former LAPD Officer Christopher Dorner was not inside; instead, the truck was occupied by two women delivering morning newspapers. We know that one officer fired 28 rounds, and that officers were so poorly arrayed that they fired toward one another, adding to the confusion in the predawn darkness.

What we don't know are the names of the officers involved. That's because the LAPD, which once was a leading proponent of openness when it came to investigating and disciplining its officers, has in recent years quietly retreated from that history. Boards of rights, where serious discipline against officers is meted out, once were open to the public; now they are closed. The names of officers involved in serious uses of force once were routinely released; now they are often withheld.

Not all of that is the LAPD's fault. Police unions statewide have fought hard to protect the identities of officers involved in shootings, and a case testing the question of how much information departments should release is scheduled to be heard by the California Supreme Court next month.

It is natural that police unions take the position they do on this matter: Their members of course prefer anonymity. But what's good for those unions is not what's best for society, nor is it even best for police departments. In the case of the Torrance shooting, protecting the identities of the officers involved prevents the department from receiving information that might come from the public. Someone outside the department may have spoken to one of these officers and learned things that would help investigators explore their actions or state of mind; by withholding the names, the department makes it more difficult for anyone with such information to understand its relevance.

More important, secrecy erodes a fundamental principle in the relationship between the public and its police. When a police officer fires a gun at a suspect, it represents a consummately public act, with the gravest possible consequences to members of the public — in this case, wounding two women who were only doing their jobs. The LAPD should release the names of the officers involved in this and all other shootings, not as punishment but as a routine acknowledgment that its work is public, and that the public has every right to scrutinize it.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Crime, Law and JusticeLaw EnforcementShootingsCrimeLos Angeles Police DepartmentCourts and the JudiciaryChristopher Dorner
  • The Christopher Dorner manhunt: Bad judgment by police
    The Christopher Dorner manhunt: Bad judgment by police

    Nerves are not an excuse for carelessness, particularly when the result is a fusillade directed at innocent people.

  • Manhunt for ex-LAPD officer
    Manhunt for ex-LAPD officer

    San Bernardino County sheriff's officials said late Tuesday they had recovered human remains in the burned cabin where they believed fugitive former police officer Christopher Dorner was holed up after gun battles with law enforcement officers. One lawman was killed and another wounded...

  • L.A. police chief, boss feud publicly over decision in Dorner case
    L.A. police chief, boss feud publicly over decision in Dorner case

    LAPD Chief Charlie Beck speaks out after commission head criticizes his decision on disciplining officers in Dorner mistaken-ID shooting.

  • Officers in Dorner mistaken-ID shooting will be returned to field
    Officers in Dorner mistaken-ID shooting will be returned to field

    Eight Los Angeles police officers who violated department policy when they mistakenly opened fire on two women during the hunt for Christopher Dorner will be retrained and returned to the field, LAPD Chief Charlie Beck said in a department-wide message Wednesday.

  • Boycotting the football industrial complex
    Boycotting the football industrial complex

    A few years ago, I began to feel guilty about watching football. What started it were the revelations about brain damage we now know the game caused in many retired players. But there was plenty more — the cynical commercialization of the sport, its cultish celebration of violence and...

  • The Beatles' cry of freedom: 'Money,' 50 years later
    The Beatles' cry of freedom: 'Money,' 50 years later

    In early 1964 a friend called me up and asked if I wanted to hear the new Beatles album, "With the Beatles." It had come out in Britain a couple of months before, but no one I knew had heard it, or for that matter heard of it. My friend's father, an airplane pilot, had brought it...

  • Football is America's war game
    Football is America's war game

    The NFL will be visiting London this year. Three regular-season games are set for Wembley Stadium, where the NFL has touched down annually since 2007. It's not surprising that the NFL wants to expand into new territories. Under the logic of capitalism, nothing stays still: You expand or...

  • The Obama-Netanyahu dysfunctional tango
    The Obama-Netanyahu dysfunctional tango

    The ongoing Gaza crisis seems to have broken a lot of crockery in the U.S.-Israel relationship.

Comments
Loading