Opinion
Join The Times' book club. This month's selection: "Cadillac Desert"
Opinion Editorial

Government shutdown: Where do we go from here?

The federal government's partial shutdown dragged on Thursday, with House Republicans continuing to demand changes in the 2010 healthcare law that Democrats won't accept. Meanwhile, President Obama and congressional Democrats have upped the ante in the shutdown talks: Not only do they want a "clean" bill that funds federal agencies without undermining Obamacare, but they want an increase in the debt limit with no strings attached.

They're right on principle: It would set a disastrous precedent if lawmakers in one chamber could bend the rest of Congress and the White House to their will by taking the government's annual funding or credit rating hostage. Yet it's hard to see how the current dispute will be resolved unless Democrats help the House GOP leadership find a way out of the corner Republicans have painted themselves into.

Republicans picked the fight over Obamacare mainly because a cohort of tea party-affiliated members had promised their constituents they'd do whatever it took to stop the law. Not only was the goal unrealistic, but the House GOP didn't have a fallback plan in the predictable event that Democrats stood firm behind the president's signature legislative achievement.

As bad as the shutdown is for the economy — disrupting government contractors, interrupting small-business loans, threatening the paychecks of more than 2 million federal workers, rattling the stock market — a failure to raise the debt limit in time would be far worse. Recognizing the stakes involved, House Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) reportedly told the House GOP caucus Thursday that he won't allow that to happen even if he has to rely on Democratic votes to do so. On the other hand, Boehner also has insisted that Democrats will have to give more ground on the deficit as part of any debt-ceiling bill.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and Obama have already made one real concession: accepting the House's lower cap on total spending in the stopgap bill. They insist they won't negotiate over the healthcare law or the debt ceiling, and rightly so. What they're really saying, though, is that the bargaining over entitlements, taxes and other budget issues needs to be decoupled from the shutdown and the debt limit. The trick is to find a way to do that without inviting a new round of brinkmanship a few months down the road.

Ultimately, the cycle of fiscal crises won't be broken until the two sides agree to the broad budget deal that leaders have been seeking in vain for two years. The glimmer of good news is that the sequester — the annual across-the-board cuts enacted in 2011 — is giving both sides a more powerful incentive to reach such a grand bargain, as is the widespread interest in overhauling the tax code. Now it's just a matter of getting them to the table without forcing the government to stay closed or flirting with default.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • The real reason for Washington's derivatives gift to banks

    The real reason for Washington's derivatives gift to banks

    As we embark on the seventh year since the historic collapse of the Lehman Bros. investment bank, it's clear we haven't fixed what broke the economy in 2008. Big banks still control Congress. Workers remain acutely vulnerable to another financial crisis. But we can't blame only Wall Street for...

  • Continue -- but gradually reduce -- federal risk in terrorism insurance

    Continue -- but gradually reduce -- federal risk in terrorism insurance

    The terrorists who turned the World Trade Center into rubble struck a devastating blow to the U.S. economy too, and few sectors felt it as acutely as the insurance industry. Afterward, insurers balked at providing any coverage for damage caused by further acts of terrorism, making it harder — if...

  • Republicans love to hate the IRS, but it's a model of efficiency

    Republicans love to hate the IRS, but it's a model of efficiency

    As you labor over your tax returns this month, spare a moment of sympathy for the least-loved agency in the federal government: the Internal Revenue Service.

  • How to fix what ails Congress: bring back earmarks

    How to fix what ails Congress: bring back earmarks

    There are lots of complex proposals floating around for how to end partisan gridlock in Congress. But here's a simple start: Bring back earmarked spending.

  • How banking works for people of no account

    How banking works for people of no account

    For about 10  years now, two married friends of mine, both low-paid small-town schoolteachers, have been sending a monthly check for $50 to one of their former students. They tell me he’s the poorest person they’ve ever met. Given the hardscrabble place where they’ve lived most of their lives,...

  • The GOP's budget gimmickry won't fix the deficit

    The GOP's budget gimmickry won't fix the deficit

    With Congress on spring break, many House and Senate Republicans will probably spend the next two weeks back home touting the resolutions they passed to "balance the budget" within 10 years. But the competing resolutions for fiscal 2016 won't do anything of the sort, no matter what lawmakers say....

  • The government shutdown du jour

    The government shutdown du jour

    Reprising a scene that lawmakers have acted out too often in the last four years, Congress is heading for a partial government shutdown this week because of a Republican attempt to repeal one of President Obama's high-profile initiatives.

  • A new shroud on spending in Afghanistan

    A new shroud on spending in Afghanistan

    For six years, the office of the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, which audits U.S. spending in the war-ravaged country, has submitted quarterly public reports to Congress drawn from records provided by the U.S.-led coalition supporting the still-shaky Afghan government....

Comments
Loading