Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion L.A.
Opinion Opinion L.A.

The Obamas' second first dog is a chance to talk about all dogs

Despite President Obama’s mention during his 2012 victory speech that “one dog’s probably enough,” apparently it wasn’t. The Obamas have expanded the first family with another Portuguese water dog, which they named Sunny. All we know about Sunny is that she hails from Michigan, is 14 months old and appears to be as impossibly cute as Bo, the dog that she is intended to be a playmate for, frolicking on the White House lawn.

We don’t know if the Obamas got Sunny from a breeder, but Bo came from a breeder, a respected one. Most people in the animal welfare community had hoped that the Obamas would adopt a dog from a rescue organization or a shelter, and the president said in 2008 after he was elected that his preference was to get a shelter dog. I understand that the Obamas have some constraints on their dog selection, foremost being that their daughter Malia has allergies, so their pet needed to be a hypoallergenic breed.

Still, whether Sunny came from a breeder or not, the Obamas made some admirable moves with their second first dog. They chose a dog over a year old, a reminder that there are plenty of wonderful dogs out there for adoption that are not little puppies. And in honor of Sunny’s arrival at the White House, the Obamas made a donation, in an undisclosed amount, to the Washington Humane Society.

Wouldn’t it be great if everyone who got a dog from a breeder also made a contribution to a local rescue group or shelter? Across the country, rescuers and shelters work hard to care for thousands of homeless animals and adopt them out.  Increasingly, I run across people who have adopted a dog or cat from a shelter or rescue group and found a remarkable pet.

But there is a place for responsible breeding. Wayne Pacelle, chief executive of the Humane Society of the U.S., has said as much and only cautions people to avoid backyard breeders (who may be overbreeding their dogs or keeping them in bad housing) and pet stores, the overwhelming majority of which get their dogs from puppy mills. The only exception is a pet store that follows a humane model and only gets its animals from shelters or rescue groups. (There are a few in Los Angeles.)

Puppy mills -- large-scale commercial breeders -- are technically not illegal (unfortunately) but are governed by minimal standards of health and safety and often don’t meet those, although they are subject to federal inspection. Nonetheless, they are usually little more than factory farms where dogs are bred too often and kept under horrible, often filthy conditions. Puppy mill dogs sold on the Internet are subject to no regulation at all. But the U.S. Department of Agriculture is working to change that. The department wants to implement a new rule that will require large-scale breeders selling over the Internet or by mail or phone to be licensed and inspected under, at least, the existing federal standards.

The White House -- now the home of what seem to be two responsibly bred dogs -- should make that rule final.


Run, Joe Biden, run!

College: It's not just 'Made in the U.S.A.'

Another shark attack in Hawaii -- revenge for sharkfin soup?

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Hurricane Katrina and the tyranny of magical thinking

    Hurricane Katrina and the tyranny of magical thinking

    Floodwater was everywhere — muddy-brown and streaked in pockets by an oily film. It covered the streets. It covered the lawns. It covered plazas and parking lots. And it lapped softly up against my porch, threatening to crest the lip and continue on through my front door.

  • Opinion newsletter: Time to start taking Trump seriously?

    Opinion newsletter: Time to start taking Trump seriously?

    Good morning. I'm Paul Thornton, The Times' letters editor, and it is Saturday, Aug. 29. Times journalist Ruben Salazar) was killed in East Los Angeles 45 years ago today. Here's a look back at the week in Opinion. Subscribe to the newsletter If you ask Donald Trump, part of the U.S. Constitution...

  • Will L.A.'s Olympic ambitions hurt or help the river restoration?

    Will L.A.'s Olympic ambitions hurt or help the river restoration?

    City analysts raised concerns this week that Los Angeles' bid to host the 2024 Summer Olympics underestimated the cost of building an Olympic village along the Los Angeles River to lodge 17,000 athletes.

  • It's the 10th anniversary of Katrina, and I don't know how to feel

    It's the 10th anniversary of Katrina, and I don't know how to feel

    Last month, my mother mentioned that she would be out of town on the 10th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina. When my sister admonished her to stay home, my mother replied, "Why? I wasn't here when it hit."

  • What Americans need: An 'idiot-proof' retirement system

    What Americans need: An 'idiot-proof' retirement system

    Volatility in the stock market over the last couple of weeks has caused enormous unease among investors big and small. Tens of millions of people with much of their retirement money in the market are worried about seeing a sudden plunge in prices. Many of these people will sell their stock to protect...

  • A smaller, better L.A. County jail?

    A smaller, better L.A. County jail?

    A majority of the Board of Supervisors wants a smaller jail. Numerous reform advocates and thinkers want a smaller jail. The Times wants a smaller jail — because for too many years the county has squandered one opportunity after another to provide more humane and effective treatment to accused...