Opinion
Reading Los Angeles: Join The Times' new book club
Opinion Opinion L.A.

Ukraine crisis: One small optimistic sign

It sounds as if someone in the Obama administration has been re-reading George F. Kennan, who (as I noted in my column) advocated a policy of “containing” Russian expansionism — but always giving Moscow’s rulers a face-saving way to back down.

“It is a sine qua non of successful dealing with Russia that the foreign government in question should remain at all times cool and collected,” Kennan wrote in 1947, “and that its demands on Russian policy should be put forward in such a manner as to leave the way open for a compliance not too detrimental to Russian prestige.”

What does that mean in 2014, when Russian troops have occupied the Crimean peninsula (once part of Russia, now part of Ukraine) and threatened intervention to protect Russian-speakers elsewhere whether they need protection or not?

PHOTOS: A peek inside 5 doomed dictators' opulent lifestyles

In the short run, it means taking the optimistic view that Russian President Vladimir Putin may have been surprised by the volume of foreign opposition his moves produced, and might be willing to accept the offer of some “off-ramps” to help deescalate the crisis.

In that spirit, the administration wants to send international observers into Crimea to protect the rights of Russian-speakers there, thus meeting one of Putin’s concerns and allowing all those soldiers in Russian uniforms to return to their barracks.

And the administration hopes to persuade Putin to view Ukraine’s presidential election, scheduled for May 25, as a vehicle for putting a new government in place. (Putin says the current government in Kiev isn’t legitimate, although he doesn’t seem to think ousted President Viktor Yanukovich has a political future either.)

Meanwhile, the Obama administration hopes to build support in Europe for more economic and political sanctions against Russia, especially sanctions targeted at the bank accounts of oligarchs in Putin’s inner circle; but not to impose them just yet, mostly to use them as a threat.

Will any of this work? Too early to tell. One key factor limiting Western pressure on Putin is the hesitance of European countries whose economic interests in Russia are greater than ours. The European Union is meeting Thursday to consider sanctions.

One small optimistic sign: So far, the Ukraine crisis hasn’t spilled over into Russian policy on other issues such as Syria and Iran. Russia and the United States were already at odds over Syria, but on one issue — Syria’s promise to relinquish chemical weapons — they’re still cooperating. And there’s been no sign of Russia walking away from the six-nation alliance pressuring Iran to curtail its nuclear enrichment program. It’s not a full-scale Cold War yet.

ALSO:

The dawn of Cold War II

What's behind Russia's moves in Ukraine? Fear of NATO

$1 billion in U.S. aid to Ukraine? Who are we, Santa Claus?

Follow Doyle McManus on Twitter @DoyleMcManus

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Crisis in Ukraine
    Crisis in Ukraine

    Ukraine's worst unrest since the 1991 collapse of the Soviet Union was sparked by ousted President Viktor Yanukovich's decision to scrap a deal with the European Union in favor of closer ties with Russia.

  • When rulers go bad: A peek inside 5 doomed dictators' opulent lifestyles
    When rulers go bad: A peek inside 5 doomed dictators' opulent lifestyles

    By Sara Lessley, guest blogger Well, what a surprise: Ukrainian strongman Viktor Yanukovich had a palace. A really, really nice country estate a few miles out of town. That thousands of previously banned average Ukrainians stampeded to check out after he, uh, left town in a big hurry in late February....

  • Agreement on Ukraine could vindicate use of economic sanctions
    Agreement on Ukraine could vindicate use of economic sanctions

    Assuming it doesn't unravel — a big assumption — the agreement on the future of Ukraine announced Thursday is preferable to the continuation of a conflict in which 5,000 people have died and nearly a million have been displaced. The deal, negotiated by Russia, Ukraine, France and Germany, calls...

  • Kiev, not Moscow, should be the choice for marking V-E Day
    Kiev, not Moscow, should be the choice for marking V-E Day

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel and British Prime Minister David Cameron have rightly turned down Vladimir Putin's invitation to go to Moscow on May 9 to mark the 70th anniversary of the Allies' victory in Europe, and President Obama may soon follow suit.

  • It's time for the U.S. to give Ukraine a defensive military boost
    It's time for the U.S. to give Ukraine a defensive military boost

    Fearful of provoking a new Cold War with Russia, the Obama administration has for months resisted pleas that it provide weapons to the government of Ukraine. This page has supported that cautious policy, worrying that military assistance to the government in Kiev would seem to create a proxy war...

  • The West can't placate Putin; it needs to help Kiev fight back
    The West can't placate Putin; it needs to help Kiev fight back

    As Western countries respond to the resumption of all-out war in Ukraine, they must ensure that the driving force behind the hostilities — Moscow — pays a greater cost for the rising civilian death toll. European Union foreign ministers are set to meet Thursday to discuss deepening sanctions against...

  • U.S., Russia should return to on-site inspections for treaty claims
    U.S., Russia should return to on-site inspections for treaty claims

    The ongoing diplomatic back-and-forth between the United States and Russia would have you believe that the future viability of the history-making Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty is nil. That would represent a major setback for arms control — and the security of the world. Beyond banning...

  • Kiev's brutal strategy in eastern Ukraine
    Kiev's brutal strategy in eastern Ukraine

    In mid-December, President Obama signed into law the Ukraine Freedom Support Act, which, among options for more sanctions against Russia, calls on the White House to provide Kiev with assistance for internally displaced persons as well as to cooperate with international organizations to distribute...

Comments
Loading