Festival of Books
Everything you need to know about the Festival of Books
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

Don't throw cold water on the ALS ice bucket challenge

To the editor: Michael Hiltzik concedes that the degenerative condition ALS is a terrible disease with a fatal outcome. But, he says, it is a rare disease; he wonders if it is worth all this attention compared with other problems. ("A few (impolite) questions about the ice bucket challenge," Aug. 18)

ALS may be rare, but if it affects your family, then it isn't. My family watched my beautiful daughter in law, age 49, go through the stages of ALS to her ultimate death.

It is a horrific experience, particularly when you consider that the victim is locked in his or her body and at the end cannot even speak and is totally paralyzed. Most sufferers die from pneumonia or respiratory failure.

The rarity of a disease should not preclude more people donating money for research. As of today, there is no cure for ALS. If the Ice Bucket Challenge can make a difference, then those moved to donate should not be told to "give a bit more thought to where you donate your money."

Penny Neugroschl, Simi Valley


To the editor: Hats off to Hiltzik for having the courage to express his true feelings about the current fad to raise money for ALS research. He understands the horrors of ALS and that the money for research is most welcome.

But Hiltzik has very real problems with the here today, gone tomorrow ice-water craze, which should promote much serious discussion.

Hiltzik points out with great clarity that although ALS is a terrible killer, the incidence in the U.S. is very, very low, and there are myriad other charities out there that are, frankly, more important toward creating a better world.

Thus, posits Hitzik, not discounting the worthiness of ALS research, if all the money you will donate to charity this year goes to ALS, you should think a bit more about the destination of your donation. I agree wholeheartedly.

Joel Rapp, Los Angeles

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Tenure isn't Easy Street for teachers

    To the editor: After 40 years teaching English in public schools, I'm really ticked off that people think tenure means that you can sit around eating bon bons, and nobody can touch you if you don't teach anything. Anybody who's ever had to control a room of 40 kids knows that you have to be on...

  • California's drought is a national issue

    To the editor: California is turning itself upside down because of the water consumed by an agricultural industry that has only a modest impact on the state's overall economy and produces food only a modest percentage of which is consumed by Californians. ("Drought unlikely to cause major damage...

  • A grandmother as president? It's time.

    To the editor: I enjoyed Meghan Daum's column where she cited Hillary Clinton's role as a "grandmother" as a positive quality for the White House. I agree that it is unfortunate that we still use the word "grandmother" as a form of negative messaging for female leaders. ("Hillary Clinton's no-knife,...

  • El Salvador's reprehensible jailing of women who have miscarriages
    El Salvador's reprehensible jailing of women who have miscarriages

    To the editor: I find it shocking that a 17-year-old house maid in El Salvador who was raped and impregnated by a neighbor and went on to suffer a miscarriage was sentenced to prison for her "crime." The Salvadoran criminal justice system isn't far off from the Spanish Inquisition or the Salem...

  • Cut back on police shootings by cutting back on guns

    To the editor: Police officers must face a population that is awash in guns. Isn't it obvious that they might be scared when routine encounters could present mortal risks? ("Curbing use of deadly force by police calls for new policies, training," April 15)

  • RFK Jr.: anti-vax and low on facts

    To the editor: Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is sullying his own good name with his demagoguery on the issue of childhood vaccination. ("Robert Kennedy Jr. apologizes for likening vaccine effects to 'holocaust,'" April 13)