OpinionTop of the Ticket

Politics of two kinds in 'Argo's' Oscar win over 'Lincoln'

Argo (movie)Zero Dark Thirty (movie)Ben AffleckBarack ObamaCentral Intelligence AgencyIranU.S. Department of State

The Oscar for best picture was won by "Argo," the true tale of a secret rescue mission in Iran during the Carter administration. It beat out "Lincoln," the story of how black Americans were rescued from slavery. Does this mean that Jimmy Carter's stock is on the rise? Nope, but Ben Affleck has certainly become a blue-chip player in Hollywood.

Politics -- not the Hollywood kind, but the Washington kind -- played a significant role in public perceptions of both films, as well as a third that was nominated for best picture. "Lincoln" is seen in some quarters as a subtle pro-Obama movie with its portrayal of a crafty progressive president promoting a radical, big-government policy through political guile and force of arms. "Argo" is a foreign affairs thriller that centers on the sacrifices of State Department officers and the heroism of the CIA. And the third film, "Zero Dark Thirty," stirred up controversy because it shows the CIA employing torture to uncover a crucial lead in the hunt for Osama bin Laden. 

Fans of former Vice President Dick Cheney are happy to see their man's support of torture vindicated by "Zero Dark Thirty," and others on the right are pleasantly surprised that the movie did not turn out to be a puff piece for President Obama. Liberals, meanwhile, see "Lincoln" as a satisfying reminder of how conservatives 150 years ago were so utterly wrong about the greatest moral issue of the 19th century.

"Zero Dark Thirty” and "Lincoln" are weightier works of art than "Argo." Affleck’s Oscar winner is a feel-good movie in which the American triumph over Iranian fanatics is all the more satisfying because it shows the U.S. actually pulled off a little victory at a time when the country seemed to be humiliatingly impotent. It is a well-done film that manages to keep the suspense boiling right up to the closing credits. Still, it does not plumb the depths of political and moral questions the way the other two movies do.

Big issues were not on the minds of academy voters, it seems. More pivotal in their choice may have been the way the well-liked Affleck was denied a nomination in the director's category. Once he began winning an armload of honors at the other awards ceremonies, his movie became the favorite to win the top Oscar. In the end, Hollywood politics -- not the other kind -- mattered the most.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Argo (movie)Zero Dark Thirty (movie)Ben AffleckBarack ObamaCentral Intelligence AgencyIranU.S. Department of State
  • If only there were an Academy Award for best stunt hand
    If only there were an Academy Award for best stunt hand

    In one episode of "Seinfeld," hapless George Costanza was hired as a stunt hand for a movie. Predictably, things went awry and poor George's hand never made a cinematic debut. In the days leading up to the 2013 Academy Awards ceremony, my own hand fared far better performing a...

  • 'Downton Abbey' breaks our hearts and shows our world being born
    'Downton Abbey' breaks our hearts and shows our world being born

    Another season of "Downton Abbey" has swiftly gone by, and those of us who are fans deserve a break.

  • Jerry Brown for governor
    Jerry Brown for governor

    Forty years have passed since Californians first elected as their governor a very young and quirkily charismatic Jerry Brown. Back then, voters made a conscious break from the past, choosing a 36-year-old Democrat with floppy collars and a philosophical bent to succeed two-term Republican...

  • The good news about offshore oil rigs
    The good news about offshore oil rigs

    Never let it be said that Mother Nature doesn't appreciate irony. A new study led by researchers at Occidental College and UC Santa Barbara has found that the oil platforms dotting the California coast are fantastic for sea life.

  • There's a better way to do immigration reform
    There's a better way to do immigration reform

    Immigration is the definitive wedge issue in American politics, but it doesn't have to be. When the Senate's Border Security, Economic Opportunity and Immigration Modernization Act failed to pass the House this year, it was the third such failure of comprehensive reform in a decade....

  • British war brides faced own battles during 1940s
    British war brides faced own battles during 1940s

    America's attitudes toward immigration have always been complicated. Influenced by world events, the U.S. embraces some immigrants and demonizes others, and it can be difficult to understand the logic. Take the story of 70,000 would-be immigrants from Britain during the 1940s who all...

Comments
Loading