Scientists have identified a simple, inexpensive compound that made cancer drugs more effective in mice and helped human patients weather the toxic side effects of
But even as they touted their experimental results, they acknowledged that their remedy was unlikely to inspire the vigorous — and expensive — research necessary to win regulatory approval and join the ranks of mainstream medicine.
The drug in question is vitamin C. When absorbed from foods such as oranges, strawberries, broccoli and kale, it feeds neurotransmitters and helps the body make collagen, among other important functions. It has also gained a cult following as an alternative form of cancer treatment thanks to Linus Pauling, a two-time winner of the Nobel Prize.
Pauling's contention that large doses of
"There's been a bias since the late 1970s that vitamin C cancer treatment is worthless and a waste of time," said Drisko, a member of the team that published the new results Wednesday in the journal Science Translational Medicine. Now, she said, "we're overcoming that old bias."
But that's only part of the problem. Even if more studies confirmed that vitamin C can help fight cancer, someone would have to steer it through the
"This is the kind of a drug that if somebody invested in it, they would not expect to make back their investment," said Morgan, who wasn't involved in the new research. "That's the issue."
At the same time, Morgan and other experts agreed that the benefits reported by Drisko and her colleagues warranted further study.
"There's certainly very clear indicators coming out of this work that further investigation is warranted," said Dr. Jeffrey White, director of the Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the National Cancer Institute.
In the new experiments, researchers examined the effects of vitamin C, also known as ascorbate, on a variety of cancer cells in the lab and in ovarian cancer cells in mice. When high concentrations entered the space between cells, it formed hydrogen peroxide.
That chemical went to work on cancerous cells in several ways: It damaged their DNA, it stressed their metabolism and inhibited their growth, said study senior author Qi Chen, a biochemist at the University of Kansas.
This weakening improved the effectiveness of traditional cancer drugs such as carboplatin and paclitaxel, according to the study.
Surprisingly, the hydrogen peroxide did not harm the non-cancerous cells, the researchers found. It's not clear why the healthy cells were spared, but the researchers said they suspected it had to do with the inefficient way cancer cells convert glucose to energy when compared with regular cells.
"Ascorbate causes an energy crisis for the cancer cells," Chen said.
A third part of the study involved a small trial of 27 patients with advanced ovarian cancer. Some of them were given vitamin C with chemotherapy, at doses of 75 to 105 grams depending on their body weight. (An orange contains about 50 milligrams of vitamin C.)
The purpose of the trial was to see whether the vitamin C sickened patients, not whether it was more effective than standard treatment. So the researchers were surprised to find that that the patients on vitamin C had more energy, experienced less nausea and generally tolerated chemotherapy better than those who did not receive it.
"We did not expect to find that," Drisko said.
In earlier studies, patients were given vitamin C in pill form, and most of it was excreted before it had a chance to be metabolized and delivered into the bloodstream, Drisko said. In the new experiments, researchers bypassed that problem by injecting the vitamin directly into the veins. That's important because the dose given to mice was extremely high — the equivalent of giving human patients the vitamin C of about 2,000 oranges.
In an article that accompanied the study, two cancer experts who were not involved in the research wrote that new drug combinations were badly needed in the fight against cancer, and that the "cocktail" of chemotherapy and vitamin C showed promise.
The findings "strongly suggest that the time has come to test ascorbate combination therapy," wrote Melanie McConnell and Patries Herst, both researchers in Wellington, New Zealand.
Though Drisko said she hoped government agencies would step in to fund larger trials, she suspected the
White, of the NIH's National Cancer Institute, complimented the study for explaining how vitamin C affects cancer cells. But he also acknowledged that some grant reviewers might view the subject with bias.
"There are certain things that carry with them a certain stigma, at least in the minds of some people who are involved with medicine and cancer research," White said. "Research like this ought to carry the day."