For most other restaurant companies, watching revenue spike 21% to $690.9 million would call for champagne. But analysts had expected the burrito chain's sales to clear $700 million when they were announced after the market closed Thursday.
Chipotle, consistently one of the industry's top-performing stocks having surged nearly 60% in 2011, plunged as much as 24% to $307.27 a share Friday. The nosedive was the steepest ever for the Denver company, which went public in 2006 and has since been at the forefront of the rapid growth of the fast-casual dining sector.
Same store sales for Chipotle restaurants open more than a year went up 8%; analysts had expected more than 10%.
Menu prices have been rising at the chain – a trend that analysts said could continue if commodity inflation keeps up. Consumer spending hasn't rebounded as much as executives would like. The cost of chicken, beef and rice kept growing.
Net income boomed 61% to $81.7 million, or $2.56 a share, from $50.7 million, or $1.59 a share from the same period a year earlier.
The company has been working to expand its nascent Asian-style ShopHouse eatery and has also boosted new Chipotle launches. Executives are also pushing ahead on efforts to use more local and sustainable fare – including sunflower oil for chips and taco shells.
Not everyone was down on the chain Friday.
"We believe Chipotle remains among the best-positioned restaurants within our coverage universe," said Wedbush Securities analyst Nick Setyan in an investor note.
The chain is expected to double its marketing spending in the third quarter after slicing it in half, a move that may offset slower growth, Setyan said.