Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion L.A.
Opinion Opinion L.A.

Et tu, Liu? A liberal justice faults a California ballot measure

Justice Goodwin Liu sidelines a ballot question on Citizens United; will liberals forgive him?

Liberal hearts leapt in 2010 when President Obama nominated UC Berkeley professor Goodwin Liu to a seat on the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. The Alliance for Justice gushed that Liu “has spent his career advocating for the right of equal justice for all, not a select, privileged few.” Here, liberals thought, was a true believer who might be able to move from the farm team of the appeals court to the U.S. Supreme Court, where he might be the first Asian American justice.

Unfortunately, the liberals’ dream was a nightmare for Senate Republicans. In a time-dishonored tradition, they blocked Liu’s confirmation, and he withdrew his name from consideration. But then, in 2011, Gov. Jerry Brown nominated Liu for a seat on the California Supreme Court. State supreme courts also have proved to be on-deck spots for future U.S. Supreme Court justices, including the liberal lion Justice William Brennan, who had served on the New Jersey Supreme Court.

But Liu, who faces a retention vote in the November election, may have blotted his copybook in the eyes of some liberals this week. Liu joined his colleagues in ordering the removal from the November ballot of a question asking voters if Congress should propose, and the California Legislature ratify, an amendment to the U.S. Constitution overturning the Citizens United ruling.

That’s the 2010 decision in which the U.S. Supreme Court held that corporations have a 1st Amendment right to spend unlimited money on independent political expenditures. As I have noted before, Citizens United is for some progressives what Obamacare is for some conservatives — an obsession that sometimes leads to derangement.

Liu didn’t just join his colleagues in shelving the anti-Citizens-United Proposition 49 until the court could hear arguments on a challenge to its legality. He filed a concurring opinion that, without committing himself to a final conclusion, suggested strongly that the Legislature exceeded its power in voting to put Proposition 49, a purely advisory measure, on the ballot.

It’s a fascinating (and I think persuasive)  opinion that examines the proposition in the light of the California Constitution’s apportioning of power between the Legislature and the people, both of whom can make binding law. Liu wrote that both parties in the case conceded that “Proposition 49 is not an initiative or a referendum because it does not propose to enact any law.”

Liu explained that a measure asking voters to advise legislators on how to vote blurs the line between the roles of the Legislature and the people. “The California Constitution draws a clear line between lawmaking by the Legislature and lawmaking by the citizenry through the ballot," he wrote. “It does not contemplate a mix-and-match approach.”

Will Liu’s opinion cost him retention votes in November or chill liberal ardor for him as a potential U.S. Supreme Court justice? I hope not, but emotions run high on anything connected to Citizens United.

After the state Supreme Court’s order, I got an email from a group called “Yes On 49/Money Out Voters In.” It said in part: “The California Supreme Court is trying to ensure that we will not be able to speak. Instead, we are determined to be even louder. Now is your chance to make your voice heard... We’ve started a petition to the court letting them know that California voters want a chance to speak out on this issue. Please sign it today. This is not over. We the People will not be silenced!”

Even by liberal judges.

Follow Michael McGough on Twitter @MichaelMcGough3

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • An end to shackling prisoners in federal court

    An end to shackling prisoners in federal court

    It's obvious that placing a criminal defendant in handcuffs and leg shackles runs the risk of prejudicing a jury. But even when only a judge is present, a policy of shackling a defendant violates his dignity, mocks the presumption of innocence and offends what the Supreme Court has called the "dignity...

  • Joseph Stiglitz explains why the Fed shouldn't raise interest rates

    Joseph Stiglitz explains why the Fed shouldn't raise interest rates

    As central bank governors, Federal Reserve officials, economists and reporters convene for the annual economic policy retreat in Jackson Hole, Wyo., this weekend, the question on everyone's mind is: Will the Fed raise interest rates come September?

  • Using cap-and-trade money for road repair doesn't pass muster

    Using cap-and-trade money for road repair doesn't pass muster

    To many California Republicans, it looks like a perfect match. On the one hand, the state can no longer ignore the deferred maintenance of its roads and bridges, not to mention the need for new ones in some areas. On the other, the state has a big pot of money that more than doubled in size to...

  • Ohio's nonsensical attack on abortion rights

    Ohio's nonsensical attack on abortion rights

    A bill in the Ohio Legislature that would ban a woman from having an abortion solely because of a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome is blatantly unconstitutional and probably unenforceable.

  • Face it, most millennial dads are hypocrites

    Face it, most millennial dads are hypocrites

    Around the time my firstborn was learning to walk, my wife and I tried a tag-team approach to parenting. I'd take most of the early morning shifts and then head to the office. Most evenings, no matter what was happening at work, I'd log back in at home, and my wife would pursue her career as a...

  • Why L.A.'s crime rise is no surprise

    Why L.A.'s crime rise is no surprise

    After more than a decade of decline, violent crime in Los Angeles rose more than 20% during the first half of 2015, with felony assaults up 26% and robberies up 19%. Why, no one yet definitively knows. But there's plenty of speculation.