Endorsements
The Los Angeles Times endorsements in the March 3 election
Opinion Opinion L.A.
Opinion

Don't by fooled by pope's latest move: Carnival time is over

For all its fascination with Pope Francis, the secular media haven’t paid much attention to a papal appointment that has stirred up the Catholic blogosphere. The no-frills pope has “confirmed” (reappointed) Msgr. Guido Marini as Master of Pontifical Liturgical Ceremonies. Marini is the bespectacled priest who attends the pope at Masses and other rites.

Why is this news? Marini was Pope Benedict XVI’s collaborator in reviving elaborate “Roman” vestments (as distinguished from the simpler “Gothic” style favored after Vatican II) and other Renaissance trappings. Coincidentally, he replaced another cleric named Marini — Piero Marini — who was blamed by Catholic traditionalists for the insufficient pomp and excessive innovations of Pope John Paul II’s liturgies.

As I explained in a column several years ago: “The pope’s aides say that his choice of vestments is designed to demonstrate continuity with the church’s past. Liberals are more inclined to see it as a slap at the spirit of Vatican II.”

On the night he was elected, Francis greeted the crowd in St. Peter’s Square dressed in a simple white cassock. Although the tale may be apocryphal, it was widely reported that he refused to don the ermine-lined red cloak worn by past popes, telling Marini: “No thank you, monsignore. You put it on instead. Carnival time is over!”

Conservative Catholics feared — and liberals hoped — that Marini would soon be packed off to an obscure bishopric. Instead, he has remained.

Does this mean Francis is a closet “rad trad” (radical traditionalist) who opposes the way Catholic worship has been simplified and made more accessible to the laity? Hardly. He seems more of a product of Vatican II, and his disdain for “clericalism” is reflected in the style of papal ceremonies. His miters are midsized and relatively unadorned; the “skyscraper” headdresses favored by Benedict seem to have been put back in mothballs.

Still, retaining Marini is an olive branch to traditionalists. At the same time, it may signal Francis’ self-confidence.

In an interview before Marini’s official reappointment, Francis said: “You say that my papal master of ceremonies is of a traditionalist character. And many have asked me about my choice to remove him from office and be replaced. I said no, just that I prefer him to even benefit me by his traditional formation and at the same time, so he is formed in the same way by my emancipated formation.”

Marini may not be able to persuade Francis to dress Renaissance-style, but he may be able to dissuade him from wearing tacky ultra-modern vestments.

Still, it’s pretty clear who has the upper hand. Carnival time really is over.

ALSO:

How to prepare for the coming 'blood moon' apocalypse

Stay-at-home moms: The sad truth behind those rosy media stories

Boston Marathon bombing survivor: My best days are the ones normal people take for granted

Follow Michael McGough on Twitter @MichaelMcGough3

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • Pope Francis, Esquire's 'Best Dressed Man of 2013'
    Pope Francis, Esquire's 'Best Dressed Man of 2013'

    There’s a whiff of publicity stunt about Esquire magazine’s decision to name Pope Francis its “Best Dressed Man of 2013.”  But the magazine’s editors are pretty astute in recognizing that the pope’s “black shoes and unadorned, simplistic...

  • Trying to put daylight between Obama and the pope
    Trying to put daylight between Obama and the pope

    Pope Francis is everyone's man of the year, so if you're a critic of President Obama you might want to try to portray the president as anti-pope. It sounds crazy, but that's exactly what two former U.S. ambassadors to the Vatican try to do in a bizarre op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal.

  • Is Pope Francis purging conservative cardinals?
    Is Pope Francis purging conservative cardinals?

    Journalists and liberal Roman Catholics are making much — perhaps too much — of Pope Francis’ decision to remove a conservative American cardinal from the congregation that helps choose bishops. The New York Times said that the pope “moved … against”...

  • Who killed at CPAC, the GOP's red meat 2016 auditions?
    Who killed at CPAC, the GOP's red meat 2016 auditions?

    The fervent Republicans who throng the Conservative Political Action Conference every year aren't representative of the American electorate. They aren't even representative of the GOP electorate. For four of the last five years, their straw poll for president has chosen Rand Paul or Ron Paul....

  • The Obama administration is seeking the right deal with Iran
    The Obama administration is seeking the right deal with Iran

    The negotiating endgame with Iran is upon us. What terms are acceptable?

  • How Abraham Lincoln said that black lives matter
    How Abraham Lincoln said that black lives matter

    A decade and a half into the 21st century, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 is under fire, and white-on-black violence brings the cry that black lives matter. As we approach the 150th anniversary of the assassination of President Lincoln, we would do well to reconsider his most famous...

Comments
Loading