Join The Times' book club. This month's selection: "Cadillac Desert"
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

$15,000 for a knee-icing machine?

To the editor: David Lazarus' column on a knee-surgery patient's bill of more than $15,000 for a cooling machine that he didn't have to pay for after a prior operation casts a much-needed light into the darkness of health insurance companies. ("Same surgery, different price: Patient gets $15,000 bill second time," Column, July 3)

One of the most astounding aspects of this case was not even discussed: The amount of money charged to rent a cooling machine is absurdly high. How can an equipment company possibly justify billing Anthem Blue Cross more than $15,000 for a few weeks of renting?

This points out why medical care in America costs so much and provides so little for the money. We are No. 1 in the world in health expenditures but were ranked 37th by the World Health Organization in 2000 in the quality of our health system.

Shame on the pharmaceutical and equipment companies, as well as insurance companies, that take us all for a ride.

Susan E. Sklar, MD, Long Beach


To the editor: The patient was billed more than $15,000 for using a cooling machine. I bought my cooling machine last year for $275.

This year I needed another knee surgery, for which I again used the ice machine previously purchased. I paid $50 for a new (sterile) knee pad and three Velcro wraps.

My concern is that Medicare and private insurance companies are being billed more than $15,000 for this machine. Obviously the patient, at 64, is not old enough to qualify for Medicare, because the machine is covered by Medicare for knee-replacement surgeries.

But if insurance companies, including Anthem and Medicare, are getting billed this much, it is beyond outrageous. That inflated billing must be stopped. Thanks to Lazarus for his investigative journalism.

Diane Baker, Corona del Mar

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • NFL teams get assist from Goldman Sachs in dodging taxes

    To the editor: The article quotes a sports economist who says the way investment bank Goldman Sachs structures deals to build stadiums like the one proposed for the NFL in Carson — by creating a public authority — saves the teams perhaps hundreds of millions of dollars by avoiding property and...

  • College feminists deserve praise, not scorn

    To the editor: Why is Meghan Daum so skeptical of feminists who are trying to shed light on chronic sexual harassment and rape on college campuses? Young women who share their painful stories of rape and trauma should be praised for their courage; their supporters should not be seen as "ignorant...

  • As long as he stays in Russia, Snowden's a traitor

    To the editor: Lest anyone think based upon one letter writer's opinion that Edward Snowden "should be invited to return to his home and receive the recognition and acclaim he has earned" is a notion shared by all, I for one strongly disagree with the tenor of his letter.

  • For these parents, 'what if your kid is transgender?' isn't hypothetical

    For these parents, 'what if your kid is transgender?' isn't hypothetical

    Last week, UCLA geneticist and pediatrician Eric Vilain and Northwestern University psychologist Michael Bailey took to The Times' Op-Ed page to discuss the development of transgender and gender dysphoric youths. As the headline suggests, their piece was novel in that it was directed at the parents...

  • Immigration and the drought: How many newcomers can California tolerate?

    Immigration and the drought: How many newcomers can California tolerate?

    To the editor: Apparently Stanford academic Victor Davis Hanson and his fellow travelers at Californians for Population Stabilization (CAPS) have stumbled onto the root cause of our drought: foreign-born immigrants. How foolish of the rest of us to think it was a lack of rain and snow. ("Group...

  • 'Housing first' isn't a novel strategy on homelessness

    To the editor: The article about the tremendous success of "housing first" in Utah eloquently describes how that approach is the real solution to chronic homelessness. Utah's success is indeed noteworthy, but its effort is not truly novel. ("Utah is winning the war on chronic homelessness with...