The TV ratings were up, but some people wondered if
The gambit appears to have worked: An average of 43 million total viewers tuned in to TV's biggest awards show, according to Nielsen. That was up 6% compared with last year's much-criticized ceremony hosted by
In the key demographic of adults ages 18 to 49 that largely determines the rates advertisers pay for commercial time, the Oscars earned a 12.9 rating, essentially flat with last year's 13.0. Among men under age 35, the ceremony climbed 4% and it was up 8% in teens.
But it was in the world of Twitter and social-media sharing where these Oscars — beamed live from the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood — really shone. During the telecast 11.2 million tweets poured forth from 2.8 million unique users, according to Social Guide — a 75% increase from last year's activity.
In taking her selfie with Streep and the others, DeGeneres invited viewers to retweet the image. It became the first image to be retweeted more than 2 million times, briefly crashing the microblogging platform. After such a stunt, the ultimate best picture win for the historical epic
"That was really gold, that was beautiful," Steve Minichini, chief innovation and growth officer at ad firm TargetCast, said of the star-studded selfie.
"It was a great example of how social media can be incorporated into a live telecast, encouraging viewers to tune into the show and take part in it," said Brad Adgate, an analyst for Horizon Media in New York.
Of course, it's hardly certain that social media deserves the credit for Sunday's viewership gain.
The Oscar producers sounded satisfied on Monday.
"Our experiences with producing the Oscars last year and then 'The Sound of Music Live' in December showed us the impact of social media and real-time viewership on ratings," producers Neil Meron and Craig Zadan wrote in a joint statement. "Fortunately for us, not only is Ellen a fantastic entertainer, she is extremely adept at using her social media platforms to expand and engage her fans ... It seems our plan worked out very well indeed!"
But in a paradox that points out the difficulties in trying to appeal to audiences on multiple media platforms these days, the Twitter stunts may not have necessarily made for great TV, Minichini added.
"From a social media standpoint, it was a huge win," he said. "But it was really geared for social media. It made for a boring live telecast."
That point was echoed by many TV critics. The Times' Mary McNamara found DeGeneres' desultory hosting style "not as hilarious as many people clearly thought it would be."
Whether an event counts as great TV, however, may matter less and less these days. Increasingly, the big ratings go to live shows that know how to capitalize on stunts and heighten suspense on social media — exactly the playbook DeGeneres and the Oscar producers used on Sunday.
The Oscars now seem to have ridden the same wave. And that means there will likely be more to come, Minichini said.
Sunday's selfies may "be a good formulaic approach for hosts and drive what kind of stunts they pull" in the future, he said.