Not only did the crime flick debut with a weak $7 million, according to an estimate from distributor The Weinstein Co., but audiences hated it. Those who saw the film assigned it a rare average grade of F, according to market research firm CinemaScore. The last movie to earn that grade was January's horror film
Pitt's movie got slaughtered by a handful of films that have been available to moviegoers for weeks. Young women have yet to tire of "The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn -- Part 2," which was No. 1 for the third consecutive weekend. The last installment in the vampire franchise grossed an additional $17.4 million this weekend, raising its domestic total to $254.6 million. That's about $8 million ahead of where "Breaking Dawn -- Part 1" was at the same point in its release last year.
The weekend after Thanksgiving is never a huge one at the box office. In fact, no film has debuted with over $10 million since 2005's "Aeon Flux." Still, ticket sales were up 42% compared with the same weekend last year.
As for "Killing Them Softly," on Sunday morning, even The Weinstein Co. wasn't trying to pretend there was any upside to the film's poor opening.
"We're disappointed, and there's no getting around that," said Erik Lomis, the independent studio's president of theatrical distribution and home entertainment. "We thought it was deserving of a wide release because it was Brad Pitt in a gangster movie."
Typically, a F CinemaScore indicates that moviegoers were expecting something far different from a movie than they ended up getting. Asked if he thought the marketing campaign for the film was off-base, Lomis replied that he thought "people just didn't like the movie."
"I think if you looked at the reviews, a lot of them were good for Brad, but they weren't all great for the movie," he said. "The headlines looked good, but maybe they weren't as great as they appeared to be."
Indeed, the film notched a strong 79% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The movie, which stars Pitt as a hit man looking into a crooked poker game, marks the second collaboration for the actor with Australian director Andrew Dominik. Unfortunately, it seems "Killing Them Softly" will follow the same trajectory as their first partnership, "The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford." That 2007 film earned strong reviews but only collected $3.9 million.
"Killing Them Softly" marks the lowest wide-release opening for Pitt in nearly two decades. He hasn't had a live-action film perform this badly in its first weekend since the beginning of his career, when his 1994
The Weinstein Co. co-financed the actor's latest film with Megan Ellison's production company Annapurna Pictures for $15 million.
The only other new film to open this weekend was the horror sequel