But, somehow or another, he managed get one of the most famous moments in recent baseball history completely mixed up.
At least according to a story tweeted out by David Cone, who won five World Series rings with the Yankees during his 17-year MLB career.
Cone attended the "SNL 40" performance in New York on Sunday celebrating the 40th anniversary of NBC's "Saturday Night Live" and has been posting first-hand accounts of the TV show on his Twitter feed. One of those tweets Wednesday involved Jay Z and former major league pitchers Curt Schilling and David Wells.
"Funniest story of the afterparty was when Jay Z thought @BoomerWells33 was Curt Shilling and asked him about bloody sock," Cone tweeted.
Schilling was a hero for the Boston Red Sox during the 2004 postseason, winning Game 6 of the American League championship series against the Yankees while pitching on an injured ankle. Schilling's blood-soaked sock from that game has become legendary.
Meanwhile, Wells was probably watching that game from home, as his San Diego Padres finished third in the National League West that year. Wells did join Schilling as part of the Red Sox pitching rotation the following year, but it's hard to imagine a die-hard Yankees fan getting confused about one of the most devastating moments in team history.
Oh, yeah, Wells also played two stints for Jay Z's Yankees during his 21-year career.
Wells and Schilling responded to Cone's story via Twitter.
Wells: "im still in shock."