Get unlimited digital access. Try it today for only $0.99.

Indianapolis Colts

Should Peyton Manning retire? Take our poll

Should Peyton Manning retire? Take our poll

Seems like kind of a silly question.

Peyton Manning has two Super Bowl rings and five NFL MVP awards. He's passed for more yards (71,940) and more touchdowns (539) than anyone in league history.

But he is going to be 40 next month and his playing ability clearly isn't close to what it used to be. Plus, he has the chance for a storybook ending to his career after winning Super Bowl 50.

Kind of seems like the question should be, why wouldn't Peyton Manning retire right now?

Yet, when given the chance to ride off into the sunset by announcing his retirement immediately after his