Los Angeles Times

OVERRATED: Mumford & Sons

With rustic harmonies and rousing melodies, all the ingredients are in place for this nouveau-folk band to win over the hardest musical heart. So why do so many of this U.K. band's pleasant songs fade into the background? Maybe it's the overabundance of breezily sincere emoting from leader Marcus Mumford or the inescapable feeling that all the earnestness in the world can't overcome the sense this music isn't saying anything new.Gareth Cattermole / Getty Images for Guinness