'Humanism as Religion'

Your editorial is right on target. Judge Hand's decreeing secular humanism a religion--which you rightly call "foolishness"--reminds me of one of my favorite Lincoln anecdotes:

When a petitioner tested the President's patience with an unusually illogical argument, Lincoln asked him: "If you would call a cow's tail a leg, how many legs would the cow have?" "Five," was the immediate answer. "Wrong!" said Lincoln. "Regardless of what you call a cow's tail, it's not a leg."

Regardless of what Judge Hand calls "secular humanism," it is not a religion. I trust you will continue to keep America aware of this truth until a higher court reverses the judge's decision.


Los Angeles

Rabbi Wolf is director of the Skirball Institute on American Values of the American Jewish Committee.

Copyright © 2019, Los Angeles Times
EDITION: California | U.S. & World