Israel Rejects U.S. ‘Advice’ on Deportations, Arrests 9 Activists

Times Staff Writer

Top Israeli officials Tuesday politely but firmly rejected U.S. arguments that they should not deport Palestinians accused of instigating disturbances in the occupied territories, saying they know best how to protect their own national security.

While the comments by Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir and Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin stopped short of promising new expulsions, they were seen here as the strongest indication yet that a move to expel at least some Palestinians is likely within days.

The remarks coincided with the arrest Tuesday of at least nine Arab activists from the West Bank and Gaza Strip who are considered by informed sources here as prime candidates for deportation.

‘Must Take Measures’


“I can’t say anything about how many will be deported,” Shamir said during a visit to the Arab village of Abu Ghosh, just west of Jerusalem, “but we must take these measures.”

As for U.S. protests that deportations violate the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949, Shamir commented: “Our answer is the same we give in similar incidents: The state of Israel knows how to defend its peace and security. We thank (the U.S.) for the advice, but we will behave according to our own understanding.”

The Fourth Geneva Convention prohibits the expulsion “for any reason whatsoever” of civilians from an area under military occupation. Israel insists that the prohibition was designed to prevent deportation for forced labor, torture or extermination, while it expels people only to ensure public order and security.

Rabin, meanwhile, told reporters after briefing the Knesset (Parliament) Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that expulsions are allowed under Israeli law and are “needed” to ensure that “there will be no resumption of outbursts of public violent disorder in the future.”


Israel radio quoted Rabin as saying to committee members: “We will tell the United States we have expelled, we are expelling and we will continue to expel; we have detained, are detaining and will continue to detain. We’ll do whatever is necessary to restore order, and this has been made clear to Washington.”

Israel bases its legal right to expel those it deems a threat to security and order on a regulation that dates back before its formation as a nation in 1948, in the post-World War I period when Palestine was governed by Britain under a League of Nations mandate.

U.S. Concerns

The comments by Shamir and Rabin followed strong representations by U.S. officials in Tel Aviv and Washington on Monday that were meant to deter any Israeli expulsions.


U.S. Ambassador Thomas R. Pickering pressed Washington’s case in a meeting with Rabin, and in Washington the Administration view was presented in a message from the State Department’s director of Israeli relations, Philip Wilcox, to Israeli Charge d’Affaires Oded Eran.

In addition to considering expulsion of Palestinians from their homeland without trial as a violation of due process, the United States has argued that deportations will only exacerbate the situation in the occupied territories by increasing tension.

Israel contends that those under expulsion order have adequate legal protections, including the right of appeal to the Israel high court.

1,000 Deportations


Israel has deported more than 1,000 Palestinians since 1968, shortly after capturing the West Bank and Gaza Strip in the 1967 Six-Day War. But the tactic has been used relatively little in the last decade, and never during that time on a scale such as is apparently being considered now.

According to Israeli media reports last weekend, security sources wanted to expel “hundreds” of Palestinians in the wake of what is now generally accepted to have been the most widespread unrest in the territories in a generation. At least 21 Arabs were killed by army gunfire and another 158 wounded during more than two weeks of violence beginning Dec. 9. About 1,000 Palestinians have been arrested.

Later, military sources said Rabin was weighing a proposal to expel up to 20 Palestinians.

U.S. officials were said Tuesday evening to be unaware of any final decision on expulsions, and Israeli sources said no decision on the expulsions is likely to be announced until after a meeting of the 10-member Inner Cabinet of senior ministers today.


Of the nine activists arrested Tuesday, seven are from the West Bank and two from Gaza. At least five were among 1,150 prisoners released from Israeli jails in a controversial May, 1985, exchange for three Israeli captives of the Lebanon war, and at least three are journalists. All are said to be active in Palestinian nationalist organizations.

While Israeli leaders appeared to be taking a hard line on deportations, defense officials Tuesday offered more reassuring news to the United States and other critics who have protested Israel’s use of lethal force against rock-throwing demonstrators.

An army spokesman confirmed that it has been decided to make riot control part of Israel’s training procedures for draftees and that the military will increase its stockpiles of non-lethal riot control gear such as tear gas and rubber bullets. The chief of staff, Gen. Dan Shomron, told Israeli defense correspondents Monday that the army had run out of some non-lethal equipment during the recent unrest.

‘Without Use of Weapons’


Rabin, meanwhile, said in an interview with the independent Haaretz newspaper that while government policy on the use of live ammunition by soldiers in the occupied territories has not changed, it is expected that the army will deal with any future problems “without the use of weapons.”

He said the army is now “better equipped to deal with violent disturbances without opening fire. This includes special helmets, shields, tear-gas grenades, and rubber bullets. And also clubs.”

The defense minister said the recent wave of unrest had been unprecedented in terms of its scale, and that “it began on a local, spontaneous basis.” Later, he said, the Palestine Liberation Organization “hitched a ride” on the disturbances, further fanning the unrest.

He said “extremist elements” hope to mark this Friday’s anniversary of the founding of the PLO’s dominant Fatah wing with more disturbances, but he promised that “our forces are deployed so that will not occur.”


“Even if we are forced to use massive force,” he added, “under no circumstances will we allow events of the last weeks to repeat themselves.”

In the most severe punishments handed down so far in the recent unrest, the Gaza military court Tuesday sentenced three men accused of throwing gasoline bombs to 30-month prison terms.

In all, according to Israel radio, military courts heard at least 72 cases Tuesday of people arrested in the December unrest, convicting at least 57 and setting one free for lack of evidence. The other cases were continued.

Most sentences during three days of expedited trials so far have ranged from 20 days to 8 months in prison plus fines of 300 to 1,000 shekels ($200-$650). The fines are equal in most cases to nearly as much or more than the typical Palestinian from the territories earns in a month. Those who cannot pay, or borrow enough from relatives, receive an additional month in jail.


Palestinian lawyers charge that many of their clients have been physically abused and that their rights are being trampled in the military’s rush to convict them. Israeli officials deny the charges.

Gaza lawyers have been boycotting the military trials for a week, and Tuesday their West Bank counterparts announced that they would join the protest.