Judge Orders Contraception

Neuborne’s use of the word sterilization is totally inappropriate. Sterilization and contraception (which Norplant is considered) are not synonymous. Sterilization, according to Dorland’s Medical Dictionary, is any procedure by which an individual is made incapable of reproduction, such as castration, vasectomy or salpingectomy. Contraception, on the other hand, is the prevention of conception or impregnation.

Norplant is a new hormonal contraceptive that is implanted under the skin and releases a hormone, similar to that found in birth control pills, over an extended period of time, approximately six years. This device prevents ovulation only. It does not sterilize. Once it is removed from the patient, ovulation resumes almost immediately, and if desired the patient can attempt to conceive.

Sterilization procedures, such as vasectomy for males, or tubal ligation for females, are considered permanent unless reversed by a surgical procedure.

In her dissatisfaction with Judge Broadman’s decision to recommend the use of Norplant for a convicted child abuser, it appears that Neuborne intentionally uses the word sterilization rather than contraception for its dramatic effect. To anyone, including myself, the idea of forced sterilization is repulsive.

It’s amazing to what lengths an individual will go to make a point. Even if it involves willful deception.

STEPHEN M. LIEB, MD

Santa Monica