Neighbor Sues Rocketdyne Over Financial Impact of Lab’s Toxics : Environment: Brandeis Institute alleges that contamination of soil and water has lowered the value of its property.
Administrators of the Brandeis-Bardin Institute have filed a federal lawsuit against their next-door neighbor Rocketdyne Inc., alleging that contamination at Rocketdyne’s Santa Susana Field Laboratory west of Chatsworth has lowered the value of the institute’s property.
The suit also alleges that the rustic family recreational center was forced to hire environmental consultants to examine the contamination, which was discovered in 1991. The suit, filed Thursday, seeks unspecified damages.
Researchers at Rocketdyne’s Santa Susana Field Laboratory conducted nuclear research in the Simi Hills for more than three decades. Despite extensive cleanup efforts in recent years, portions of the property still contain chemical and radioactive contamination, most of it at low levels.
Studies conducted in the last four years show that chemical and radiological contaminants in soil and ground water have also crossed the boundary to the Brandeis property.
People who work at or visit the institute cannot and are not using the ground water,” said Brandeis’ lawyer, Helen E. Zukin, alleging that enough toxic solvent has leaked across the property line to render the ground water undrinkable. The institute, however, has never used the ground water, she said.
Further, the suit maintains that the contamination lowers the value of Brandeis’ property should administrators ever decide to sell any of the center’s 3,100 acres. The contaminated areas of Brandeis’ land are near its boundary with Rocketdyne and is well removed from the main activity center of the institute.
“This is a complaint for property damage,” Zukin said. “We are not alleging that anyone has ever been injured.”
The suit was filed in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles because nuclear contamination lawsuits are covered by federal law, Zukin said.
Rocketdyne officials said Thursday they were caught off guard by the lawsuit, adding that they have been trying to resolve the problem with Brandeis officials and hoped that an out-of-court settlement could be reached.
“We have been working with them for years and we are surprised and saddened to see the suit,” spokesman Paul Sewell said, declining further comment.
But Zukin said the company, a division of Rockwell International Corp., has been slow and haphazard in its cleanup effort and that Brandeis officials felt that out-of-court discussions “have been exhausted.”
“They continue to be cited for cleanup violations,” Zukin said.
In 1992, the company paid $650,000 to settle a state hazardous-waste lawsuit for contamination at Santa Susana and several other Southern California locations. Currently, federal officials are conducting a criminal investigation into the events surrounding a 1994 explosion that killed two physicists at Santa Susana. Among other things, authorities are trying to determine if the explosion occurred during a scientific experiment, as Rocketdyne maintained, or if the company was attempting to secretly dispose of explosive wastes.
There is also the fear that contamination on Rocketdyne’s property will continue to spoil the Brandeis center’s land, Zukin said.
Daniel O. Hirsch, president of an environmental group that monitors the Rocketdyne facility, said the Brandeis contamination is probably “merely the front of a large, contaminated plume” on the other side of the property line that will take decades to clean.
“We don’t believe they will reach cleanup for 50 years,” Hirsch said. “And there is substantial doubt that the ground water will ever be cleaned.”
*
The Brandeis-Bardin Institute runs children’s summer camps and offers weekend retreats for adults on the sprawling, wooded campus. The center, located southeast of the Rocketdyne facility, moved to Santa Susana from New York in 1947.
Until the last decade, Hirsch said, Rocketdyne’s neighbors--as well as the public--were unaware of the nuclear work researchers were doing at the Santa Susana lab, which sits on 2,700 acres in the Simi Hills and employs 700 workers.
“Rocketdyne is the classic bad neighbor,” Hirsch said. “But instead of playing the stereo loud, they dumped cancer-causing materials into their neighbors’ backyard.”
*
Times staff writer Myron Levin contributed to this story.
