How 3% Treasury yields could reshape the investing landscape
Ten-year Treasury yields punched through the 3% level this week for the first time in four years, prompting investors to dust off their playbooks for how to trade in an era of relatively higher rates.
Rising rates isn’t exactly a new problem for markets — the 10-year yield jumped 30 basis points in January alone. But this time the rise is driven by surging commodity prices, not heady economic gains. And that has thrown a wrinkle into the discussion, particularly when it comes to equities.
“Historically, the stock market has done OK with rising inflation, provided economic momentum was also rising,” Jim Paulsen, chief investment strategist at Leuthold Group, said in a note to clients Monday. “Stocks also have performed well even when economic momentum has faded, if inflation also moderates. However, periods of stagflation have produced poor results in both the stock and bond markets.”
Here’s how some markets may react to the rise in rates:
Stocks
Since the financial crisis, stocks have paid out more than fixed-income investments, but the premium is waning: The spread between the Standard & Poor’s 500 index’s earnings yield and that of the 10-year Treasury bill is hovering near the lowest levels in eight years.
If yields push past 3%, that could alter the value proposition for equities versus fixed income for years to come, according to Chris Verrone, the head of technical analysis at Strategas Research Partners.
“This is a 35-year trend change in bonds. We think it’s just begun,” he said Monday. “We would encourage investors to consider that 1950 period, the last time bond yields went up. It took a while to go from 2% to 5%, but the trend was up and you stopped making money on the long side of the bond trade. That’s where we think we are right now.”
Emerging-market investors are taking note too. Unlike three months ago, when the jump in rates left them sanguine, there’s more reason for worry now; for example, trade spats and signs that synchronized global growth is slowing. Commodity-driven inflation could also lead to a faster pace of monetary tightening that would disproportionately harm emerging markets, according to Per Hammarlund, chief emerging-markets strategist at SEB in Stockholm.
Corporate credit
The least creditworthy companies have benefited from low benchmark yields, but if easy money disappears and borrowing costs rise, servicing debt would become more expensive. For now, corporate credit is hanging in, with high yield spreads remaining off the tightest level since before the financial crisis.
“The question, of course, is how long can this last,” said Peter Boockvar, chief investment officer of Bleakley Financial Group, noting that current debt levels for S&P 500 companies outside of banks are at extremely high levels. “Stating the obvious, high debt levels along with higher interest rates is not the best combination.”
Matt Maley, an equity strategist at Miller Tabak & Co., also says staggering levels of investor leverage pose a risk. As rates rise, lenders increase costs on margin accounts, which in turn prompt a gradual unwind of leverage that’s become too expensive, he said.
“When everyone has been talking about whether higher rates impact the economy, the more important thing is how it will impact leverage,” Maley said by phone. “It creates a headwind for the market.”
Debt in New York Stock Exchange margin accounts is the highest on record, yet the measure necessarily rises when the value of stocks — which are used as underlying collateral — rises. And it looks relatively small: Margin debt is less than 3% of the total NYSE market capitalization. For that reason, leverage levels can’t be used as a timing tool for downturns, but rather pressures markets during periods where investors need to unwind, Maley said.
U.S. dollar
As for the dollar, higher yields have slowly brought investors back to the greenback. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index is in the midst of its best four-session stretch since the 2016 U.S. election, and has seen its one-month correlations with both 10-year Treasury yields and inflation-protected peers trend higher.
Neil Dutta, head of U.S. economics at Renaissance Macro Research, attributes the pickup in the dollar and real yields to the U.S. economy’s brighter outlook compared with the rest of the world. The continuation of this dynamic would paint a mixed, but positive, picture for risk assets.
“Our sense is that in coming quarters we see the dollar strengthen against most of the majors and for U.S. real rates to continue rising,” he writes. “Stocks should like the stronger growth environment, but dollar strength and higher real yields imply tighter financial conditions, providing some offset.”
Indeed, this dollar strength stemming from rising inflation-adjusted yields could also prove self-regulating. An advancing greenback tends to weigh on commodity prices, and the jump in West Texas Intermediate crude prices has been the key driver of the advance in break-even inflation rates.
Japan effect
High hedging costs have stayed the hand of Japanese investors eyeing U.S. bonds for months now. But for some, the yield attraction is getting just too good to resist.
Dai-Ichi Life Insurance Co. has joined Daido Life Insurance Co. and Fukoku Mutual Life Insurance Co. in planning to buy foreign debt without hedging. Previously, Japanese investors had shied away from U.S. bonds on the rising expense of currency hedges.
“Yields on U.S. corporate and mortgage debt, without currency hedging, have reached attractive levels for Japanese life insurance companies,” said Yunosuke Ikeda, head of Japan FX research at Nomura Securities. “As long as U.S. 10-year yields are expected to pivot around 3%, it’s natural for life insurers to consider nonhedged investments in dollar assets.”
Nice number
Still, some in the market, such as Rabobank strategist Michael Every, see the 3% level as nothing more than a “nice round prime number of the special psychological kind.” He urged investors not to panic in a note to clients Tuesday.
“After all, the last time we got to where we are now, back in February, the 10-year rapidly retreated back to a low of 2.73%,” he wrote. “And when we breached 3% in late 2013 we rapidly followed that up with a plunge back to 1.36% in mid-2016.”
UPDATES:
11:10 a.m.: This article has been updated to include additional areas of investing impact.
This article was originally published on April 23 at 12:20 p.m.
