Our try-on tests rate the form-fitting labels Yummie Tummie, Spanx, Dr. Robert Rey, Shape fx and Assets by Sara Blakely.
Spanx Slim Cognito
$74
Visibility: The extra-wide, adjustable straps kept peeking out of the tank we wore to work -- which wouldn’t be the worst thing if the fleshy color didn’t remind us of grandma’s girdle. The bottom also crept up considerably on a 30-second walk from restroom to desk, creating a massive hip and back bulge. Ick.
Wiggle room: We nearly poked an eye out trying to contort our way into the terribly tight top. Once on, it felt more like a medical compression device than an aesthetic tummy trimmer.
Taming the beast: We were so uncomfortable, we thought it had to be doing something. And it was. Rolling up, it created pooches of hip and back fat.
Final verdict: Many successful fat-free outfits are owed to Spanx’s beloved body-shaping shorts. But Spanx misses the mark in upper-body sculpting.
* (Liz O. Baylen / Los Angeles Times)
Instant Shape by Dr. Robert Rey Convertible Strap Corset
$60
Visibility: Removable bra straps made this heavy-duty shaper a cinch to wear underneath a black cotton tank top. Vertical support spines cemented the top firmly in place and kept it from riding up after an hour of sitting. Unlike other corsets we’ve worn, these spines curved when we sat -- but bounced back into their original shape as soon as we bounced up for lunch. The plain black style is sexy and doesn’t look like a standard body shaper. Perfect under an open blazer or, for the daring, alone as a top.
Wiggle room: A Playmate-style padded bra and three rows of hook-and-eye closures make this style appear foreboding. But don’t judge a corset by its cover. Despite its heavy structure, the shaper is surprisingly comfortable and easy to get on and off.
Taming the beast: Colleagues couldn’t believe our dramatic transformation. Dr. Rey’s corset trimmed our waist, banished our back fat and even created an hourglass silhouette under an otherwise frumpy cotton top.
Final verdict: The plastic surgeon turned E! reality show star knows a thing or two about reworking bodies. Dr. Rey’s shaper lived up to its tag line and really did provide instant shape. For a mere $60, we’ll take Rey’s corset over his surgical knife any day. The winner, by a belly flop.
* * * * * (Liz O. Baylen / Los Angeles Times)
Assets by Sara Blakely Fantastic Firmers Tank
$20 to $22
Visibility: Smooth as silk, this wide-strap tank didn’t pinch our problem areas or create extra fat pockets. It doesn’t look like a stodgy shaper and can be worn on its own for everyday.
Wiggle room: We felt at ease in our Assets and could have lasted longer than the five hours we spent in the tank. But after sitting for a bit, we met with a ring around the belly -- our top had rolled up toward the heavens.
Taming the beast: Our Assets didn’t tame much. A colleague even asked if we were wearing a shaper. But the tank did reduce one spot: the bust line. Nevermind that it’s the one place we’re fine to leave alone.
Final verdict: It’s a fine layering piece but we wouldn’t rely on it for any tummy reduction.
* * (Liz O. Baylen / Los Angeles Times)
