Texas executes inmate for strangling El Paso woman in 2002
A Texas inmate who was a member of a white supremacist gang was executed Wednesday evening for strangling a woman 17 years ago over fears she would alert police about his drug operation.
Justen Hall, 38, received a lethal injection at the state penitentiary in Huntsville for the October 2002 slaying of Melanie Billhartz. Prosecutors said Hall killed Billhartz, 29, with an extension cord from his drug house in El Paso and then buried her body in the New Mexico desert.
Hall also had been charged with a second slaying, and from the Texas death chamber gurney said he apologized “from the bottom of [his] heart” to the families of both of his victims “for the pain and suffering [he] caused.”
“It should never have happened,” he said, his eyes red and watery.
His mother and a sister watched through a window a few feet away. He told them he loved them and said, “I’m going to miss you all.”
As the lethal dose of pentobarbital took effect, Hall took a couple of deep breaths, then began snoring, each snore becoming less audible. Within seconds, all movement stopped.
He was pronounced dead 19 minutes later, at 6:32 p.m. local time.
His attorneys had asked to stop the execution, alleging he was not competent to be executed and had a history of mental illness. But a judge in El Paso last month denied the request. No other appeals were filed.
During a March 2017 court hearing on whether to have DNA testing in his case, Hall said he was “100% competent” and acknowledged killing Billhartz. Prosecutors said two court-appointed experts in 2017 found Hall to be competent.
Hall was the 19th inmate put to death this year in the U.S. and the eighth in Texas. Three more executions are scheduled in Texas this year.
Billhartz’s sister, Lana Rivera, said her sibling had become involved with drugs and the wrong crowd after their mother died of cancer. But it wasn’t who she was, Rivera said, describing her sister as a fun-loving person who adored her family.
“She was trying to fill a void of my mom’s death ... Melanie was lost,” Rivera said.
Authorities said Billhartz associated with people from the drug house, including Hall, who was the district captain of the Aryan Circle gang. On the night of her murder, Billhartz accused Ted Murgatroyd, who also hung out at the house, of assaulting her.
Hall worried that if police were called, his drug operation would be discovered. Later, in a confession to police, Hall said he killed Billhartz in her truck on a dirt road outside El Paso. Hall drove back to the drug house and got Murgatroyd to help him dispose of Billhartz’s body.
She was buried in Kilbourne Hole, a volcanic crater in New Mexico located about 30 miles outside El Paso. But before burying Billhartz, Hall ordered Murgatroyd to cut off her fingers with a machete to prevent any DNA from being found under her fingernails.
At the time of Billhartz’s murder, Hall was free on bond after being charged with fatally shooting 28-year-old Arturo Diaz, a transgender woman, in April 2002. El Paso police had investigated Diaz’s death as a hate crime.
Hall was convicted of Billhartz’s death in 2005.
The details of her death remain disturbing for Elaine Rountree, Billhartz’s aunt.
“What Justen did to her, it’s still traumatizing,” she said.
Rountree recalled that just before her death, her niece had been planning for a fresh start by moving to New Mexico with her grandmother.
Rivera said her sister had “always wanted to get married and to have children, and [Hall] took all that away.”
Hall had maintained his innocence, and his lawyers filed appeals asking for DNA testing to analyze the ligature found on Billhartz’s neck. His lawyers had also argued that his confession was unreliable and that prosecutors relied on contradictory witness testimony.
But at a March 2017 court hearing, Hall told a judge his request for DNA testing was a “stall tactic.”
“I killed Melanie, and I killed Arturo. And I accept the punishment for it, and I’m ready to get it over with, you know,” said Hall, who stopped talking to his attorneys and asked that all appeals be stopped.
Rivera, 49, said she misses her sister every day.
“My faith has brought me through a lot,” Rivera said, “knowing that one day we’ll meet again.”
The Latinx experience chronicled
Get the Latinx Files newsletter for stories that capture the multitudes within our communities.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.