Mexico’s Senate approves controversial revision of body that safeguards elections

Mexican President Andres Manuel López Obrador and his wife, Beatriz Gutierrez Muller
Mexican President Andres Manuel López Obrador and his wife, Beatriz Gutierrez Muller, wave during a state visit at the National Palace in Mexico City.
(Fernando Llano / Associated Press)

Mexico’s Senate on Wednesday approved a revision of the country’s electoral institute, a move that opponents say will undercut democracy but that the president contends will save money and reduce political privileges.

Lawmakers voted 72 to 50 in favor of the controversial overhaul of the body overseeing Mexico’s elections. Opponents immediately said they would challenge the changes in the Supreme Court. Protests are planned in multiple cities.

The revision still needs to be enacted by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, but that is seen as a formality since he backs the initiative, which would reduce the size of the institute and limit its supervisory and sanctioning powers.


Some opposition lawmakers held up posters reading: “Morena wants to steal the elections,” referring to López Obrador’s ruling Morena party. Mexico has presidential elections scheduled for next year.

The legislative initiative, known as “Plan B,” was proposed by the president in December after he did not obtain enough votes in Congress for a constitutional reform that carried deeper electoral changes.

The president has repeatedly denied that the initiative could put elections in Mexico at risk, saying that it seeks to cut the National Electoral Institute’s large budget and end its privileges.

The institution that helped foster Mexico’s democracy is under attack by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador.

Dec. 1, 2022

López Obrador and his supporters have been critical of the electoral institute since 2006, when he came within 0.56% of winning the presidency and denounced his loss as fraudulent. He and his supporters launched a mass protest movement.

Despite the institute confirming his landslide victory in 2018, López Obrador has repeatedly complained of how costly it is to run elections in Mexico and sought to curtail the institute’s budget. He frequently says that the independent body is in the hands of the elite.

Some Mexicans see similarities to the rhetoric used by former President Trump and former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro ahead of elections in their countries that aimed to erode confidence in the process.


Many in Mexico see the electoral institute as a key pillar of the country’s modern democracy. After 71 years of uninterrupted single-party rule, the opposition finally broke through in 2000.

Genaro García Luna is the highest-ranking current or former Mexican official ever to be tried in the United States.

Feb. 21, 2023

López Obrador’s ruling Morena party is favored in next year’s national elections and the opposition is in disarray, which would seem to give the president little incentive to attack the electoral institute. He remains highly popular in Mexico, but is not eligible for reelection.

Lorenzo Córdova, the institute’s leader, has aggressively defended it in public and framed the initiative as a threat to Mexico’s democracy. His outspokenness has made him a frequent target of López Obrador.

After Wednesday’s vote, the institute said via Twitter that the initiative “puts at risk the equity and transparency of the elections” by weakening the sanctions the institute can apply to candidates and parties that violate campaign finance rules.

Even before Wednesday night’s vote, the opposition had called for a march in Mexico City on Sunday in defense of the institute. The opposition held a similar march in November, which was ridiculed by López Obrador, who led a larger march days later.

The president had already worried some observers by frequently attacking Mexico’s judiciary and concentrating enormous responsibility in the hands of the military, raising questions about his respect for the country’s democratic institutions.